• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Looking for my first OD pedal

+1. I've used 3 of these 6 pedals mentioned (5th Gear, Barbershop, Beta), and agree they'd be good choices as well.

I’ve used them all, save for the Terraformer, but I’ve heard enough clips and testimonials, not to mention had enough other Broughton drive pedals, to know it’s the bomb (and only a matter of time before I get one).
 
Aftershock Bass Distortion

+100 for the SA Aftershock it has ended my search. After owning all the classics, being involved with some boutique builds and going through about 50 bass distortion pedals this ended my search. It comes with three great stock sounds, can hold six with presets (more with a hub) and is easy to edit using computer or phone with the Neuro App. All the major distortion engines are there with lots of parameters to personalize and it is stereo or a dual engine!
 
I have been using a Bearfoot Blueberry for about 8 years. I keep trying other distortion pedals just out of curiosity but I keep coming back to the Blueberry. The added bonus is it is my favorite distortion pedal for guitar too. Everybody has a certain sound in their head. I don't know if this pedal will work for you but it keeps working for me.
 
Creation Audio Grizzly? A little out of the price range, but worth the stretch.
If OP is OK with a wall wart power supply (i.e. not needing 9v for a pedal board), then there are deals on the Creation Audio Holy Fire Classic OD: Invalid Link Removed or you can find many used. This is similar to the Grizzly with one less tone knob. The clean gain 'G' is utterly clean and quiet so it serves as clean boost and as blend with overdrive 'O' and distortion 'D'. The newer Holy Fire 9 is 9v friendly but costs $195 and I don't see any used. These have limited EQ (hi cut only) compared to the Terraformer but lots of bang for the buck if you're OK with the wart. I use a separate EQ with the Grizzly; chained either before or after.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BillyBA
Not sure what used prices are, but the Tech21 DP-3X sounds like it might be the ticket.

dUg_pedal-1024x357.png
 
I use an AmpTweaker Bass Tight Drive with the added bass mod (Just a clean blend I think). I always have it on for a bit of dirt but it's capable of some heavy lifting too. I tried a few others (some listed here) but hated the loss of bottom end I got from most of them. I use a Malekko B:assmaster with it occasionally to drive the rest of the band nuts....
 
No mention of the Pork Loin yet? I guess I'll be the first to recommend it, then...Can do subtle to nasty, and most importantly it sounds great in a band context. Killed my GAS for other OD/dist/fuzz boxes.
Ditto this. I have almost exclusively boutique dirt, but this box is the single dirt pedal I would keep if I could only keep one. It just simply works in the band context and is incredibly flexible when you get the internal trims set.

For reference, I also use flats and love this box. I modded it for better treble response, but it’s great stock as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frank77
After reading countless threads, I've come to some conclusions about the sound I'm after. Please keep in mind that I'm still a bass effects rookie.

1. Must be able to do subtle OD well. I don't need a very heavy OD, just something with a little grit. I play a bass with flats, so anything that can help add some upper frequencies would be cool.

2. Must sound natural (or as natural as an OD pedal can I guess). For reference, I've owned a Boss ODB-3. It sounded very digital and not at all what I'm looking for.

My price range is $150 US, and I am open to used pedals. I'm probably going to have to order online, so please keep that in mind. The two pedals I'm considering are the Source Audio Aftershock and the Electro Harmonix Bass Soul Food. Darkglass sound kind of cool, but I've never really heard them used outside of a metal/hard rock type setting.

Appreciate the help!

Edit: Forgot to add the Mad Professor Blueberry OD to the list.
If you can find a used Darkglass Alpha-Omicron in your price range, you can get some wonderful low gain grit out of it. Don't be fooled by the demos that crank it up to 11. Same for the Damnation Audio MBD-1, but not sure you can find one close to $150. Lastly, the Crazy Tube Circuits Planet B is wonderful. I bet you can find a used one in your price range, especially since they have the Plus version now, which to wouldn't need with what you said about
your needs.
 
I have been using a Bearfoot Blueberry for about 8 years. I keep trying other distortion pedals just out of curiosity but I keep coming back to the Blueberry. The added bonus is it is my favorite distortion pedal for guitar too. Everybody has a certain sound in their head. I don't know if this pedal will work for you but it keeps working for me.
I have a Fuzzrocious Darkest Driving, which is similar to a blueberry. I love the tone of it, has that nice slightly farty tube-y grit :D
 
The Nobels ODR-1 is great for the kind of dirt you want.

The Visual Sound “Open Road” is based on the ODR-1 and might be built a little more sturdily.

Either can be found used for well under $100...

I went on a similar tone quest 3-4 years ago; this thread chronicles what I tried and what I thought
of them:
Looking for a dynamic, uncompressed, mild overdrive...
 
Wow, lots more pedals mentioned here than what I had considered! Keep the recommendations coming. Still would love to hear opinions on the Bass Soul Food, SA Aftershock, and the Mad Professor Blueberry OD.

SA Aftershock is excellent, but IMO you do have to be willing to faff around programming the thing to make it worth your while. I couldn't make myself get into that. It's a good sounding pedal though. Mad Professor Blueberry is also a great sounding pedal, but I don't see it giving you the extra bit of high frequencies you're looking for. It's a decidedly low middy pedal. Bass Soul Food is very good, in a somewhat similar territory to the Blueberry but not as focused on the low mids.

I still think given what you described that the Hot Wax is a better choice, unless you think playing around with the Aftershock's deep feature set sounds good in which case maybe give that a try.