• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Man Laws II

René_Julien;8859506 said:
I propose you are either not a drinker of alcoholic beverages or you are a drinker of alcoholic beverages.
Free of choice.

Certainly, but nothing about "beer is good" implies "not drinking is unmanly". I'd use dog-ownership as an analogy ... dogs are generally treated as manly in the Man Laws, but no Man Law says that owning a dog is necessary to receive a Man Card.

As for dividing alcoholic beverages into "manly" and "unmanly" that's definitely an idea worth running with, but I think it can happen in parallel with "beer is good".

w.r.t. dogs, I'd like to propose a refinement of an earlier suggestion:

"Any dog that has traveled in a woman's purse at any time in its adult life counts as a cat for the purposes of Man Law."
 
Smoking - anything - is not subject to Man Laws, IMO. If you are foolish enough to light something on fire and intentionally breathe in the smoke created by it, and can STILL be manly, you are manly, but no more so than a man that is sensible enough to NOT do so.

It is not in any way to be equated with the imbibing of manly (i.e. beer) beverages in bestowing Manliness.

Actually I like this as a man law. I'm seconding this.
 

Latest posts