• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Marshall 1555 cab speaker advice

Anyone own one of these? Considering replacing the stock sidewinder speaker and looking for recommendations from anyone who’s done this before? Cab dimensions are 38x22x14 with the 45 degree angled baffle at the bottom. Will be using it to play rock/blues out of a 4 string passive bass. I’ve seen a lot of replacement speaker info on the 1550 cab but nothing really on the 1555.

The cab will be driven by a 500 watt 4 ohm head, so putting out about 280w with an 8 ohm speaker.
 
My thought and opinion would have you not put any money into the cab. Maybe try and sell it for a newer, more modern cab.
Why do you want to swap out the speaker? Bass cabs are way trickier to "upgrade" than (it seems) most folks realize.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
You don't seem to indicate that anything is wrong with the stock speaker. Unless you are willing and able to do the necessary engineering, leave it alone. If the cab does not suit your needs, sell it and get something else. If you love the cab, but need more SPL, hunt down a matching cab (I do understand this will probably not be easy).

The internal volume of the cab and tuning of the port must be designed to work with the driver. You could spend a lot of money on a driver that is arguably far superior to the stock driver and wind up with far worse performance. Buying a driver with a higher RMS power rating is no guarantee that the driver will actually handle more power in the cab.

The driver's RMS power rating is a measure of how much heat the voice coil can dissipate without burning. With bass cabs, you need to be concerned with the mechanical power handling below 100hz. In a well designed cab the mechanical power handling may be as low as 50-60% of the drivers RMS power rating. If the cab is not designed specifically to work with the driver, it can be even worse.

Additionally, if the cab is not tuned to work well with the driver, the low frequency response may be uneven or weak. Here is how a ported cab works. At higher frequencies the cab performs pretty much like a sealed design. As the frequency goes lower, at some point the driver's output will start to decrease. The port must be tuned so that it reinforces and smoothly extends response to a lower frequency. As the frequency goes even lower, the port will reproduce more and more of the sound. At the tuning frequency (Fb), the port is producing most of the sound and also providing maximum suppression of the driver's cone movement. Below Fb, output drops of quickly and driver excursion increase quickly, so it's a bad idea to feed the cab a lot of power very far below Fb.
 
You don't seem to indicate that anything is wrong with the stock speaker. Unless you are willing and able to do the necessary engineering, leave it alone. If the cab does not suit your needs, sell it and get something else. If you love the cab, but need more SPL, hunt down a matching cab (I do understand this will probably not be easy).

The internal volume of the cab and tuning of the port must be designed to work with the driver. You could spend a lot of money on a driver that is arguably far superior to the stock driver and wind up with far worse performance. Buying a driver with a higher RMS power rating is no guarantee that the driver will actually handle more power in the cab.

The driver's RMS power rating is a measure of how much heat the voice coil can dissipate without burning. With bass cabs, you need to be concerned with the mechanical power handling below 100hz. In a well designed cab the mechanical power handling may be as low as 50-60% of the drivers RMS power rating. If the cab is not designed specifically to work with the driver, it can be even worse.

Additionally, if the cab is not tuned to work well with the driver, the low frequency response may be uneven or weak. Here is how a ported cab works. At higher frequencies the cab performs pretty much like a sealed design. As the frequency goes lower, at some point the driver's output will start to decrease. The port must be tuned so that it reinforces and smoothly extends response to a lower frequency. As the frequency goes even lower, the port will reproduce more and more of the sound. At the tuning frequency (Fb), the port is producing most of the sound and also providing maximum suppression of the driver's cone movement. Below Fb, output drops of quickly and driver excursion increase quickly, so it's a bad idea to feed the cab a lot of power very far below Fb.

Thanks so much! Nothing is wrong with the stock, was just looking for a bit more. I like your idea of finding another, I like the hunt. Given all of the information you provided, I'll just leave this one as is!
 
You don't seem to indicate that anything is wrong with the stock speaker. Unless you are willing and able to do the necessary engineering, leave it alone. If the cab does not suit your needs, sell it and get something else. If you love the cab, but need more SPL, hunt down a matching cab (I do understand this will probably not be easy).

The internal volume of the cab and tuning of the port must be designed to work with the driver. You could spend a lot of money on a driver that is arguably far superior to the stock driver and wind up with far worse performance. Buying a driver with a higher RMS power rating is no guarantee that the driver will actually handle more power in the cab.

The driver's RMS power rating is a measure of how much heat the voice coil can dissipate without burning. With bass cabs, you need to be concerned with the mechanical power handling below 100hz. In a well designed cab the mechanical power handling may be as low as 50-60% of the drivers RMS power rating. If the cab is not designed specifically to work with the driver, it can be even worse.

Additionally, if the cab is not tuned to work well with the driver, the low frequency response may be uneven or weak. Here is how a ported cab works. At higher frequencies the cab performs pretty much like a sealed design. As the frequency goes lower, at some point the driver's output will start to decrease. The port must be tuned so that it reinforces and smoothly extends response to a lower frequency. As the frequency goes even lower, the port will reproduce more and more of the sound. At the tuning frequency (Fb), the port is producing most of the sound and also providing maximum suppression of the driver's cone movement. Below Fb, output drops of quickly and driver excursion increase quickly, so it's a bad idea to feed the cab a lot of power very far below Fb.
Thanks for the great primer on bass speaker replacement and \cabinet design. I now know more about bass speaker design
 
Anyone own one of these? Considering replacing the stock sidewinder speaker and looking for recommendations from anyone who’s done this before? Cab dimensions are 38x22x14 with the 45 degree angled baffle at the bottom. Will be using it to play rock/blues out of a 4 string passive bass. I’ve seen a lot of replacement speaker info on the 1550 cab but nothing really on the 1555.

The cab will be driven by a 500 watt 4 ohm head, so putting out about 280w with an 8 ohm speaker.
I don’t see that cab as providing any more of a “vintage” sound as TL type single 15”(typically loaded with an EVM)and that kind of cab would serve bass frequencies a lot better. Are you going for the look? You’d be better off with an older Sunn 2x15, which is only slightly larger. What kind of amp are you using?
 
  • Like
Reactions: agedhorse
I do like the look, I also have the 5518 cab that will sit on top of it. As far as amps, I have a Markbass casa (Michael league signature amp) as well as a custom power amp very similar to the Demeter Minnie 800, only this one is 500w at 4 ohms. If I go the custom amp route I have a few tube pre amps to choose from as well.