I use a Thunderbird and a Stingray for most of our stuff and every now and then I'll bring my Geddy Fender Jazz for some of our acoustic songs.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

This. I always have a backup, but I stick to just one bass per show.I've never used more than one bass live at any given show, but I have been known to bring a backup along, especially on tour...
Did he say why he thought a Jazz bass was a better choice? Sounds like he was "listening with his eyes" to me.From the "Go Figure" Department:
I decided to just use just my P bass on this gig. It's strung with flatwounds and the set was a mix of an 1) original slow blues, 2) a slightly funky original rock tune, 3) a straight ahead original rock tune, 4) a cover of Pink Floyd's "Wish You Were Here", 5) a cover of Neil Young's "Old Man", and 6) an original slow ballad original where the guitarist plays acoustic. I played 1 and 2 finger style, 3 with a pick, 4 finger style, 5 with a pick, and 6 fingerstyle.
My friend was in the audience and I told him to listen and give me constructive criticism afterward. He didn't know I own a Jazz and that I was debating whether to do switches or just take one bass.
I come off stage and the first thing he says is "It was good but you should get a Jazz bass for those songs"
Later, I go over to say hi to the guitarist's wife and she says "My friend that was here earlier said to tell the bass player how good the bass sounded".
Goes to show it's subjective....
And I'm still debating in my own mind which bass sounds better for this new band and some of these songs.
Did he say why he thought a Jazz bass was a better choice? Sounds like he was "listening with his eyes" to me.
Really, the decision to play flats or rounds is going to make WAY more noticeable difference to your tone than the choice of bass.
I will usually use either my fretted and fretless for shows, or my fretted and EUB. To manage this, I use a Radial BassBone. It is the best pedal for what you want to do, in matching both basses signals. It's also got a couple other useful tidbits that the soundguys that I work with rely upon (mainly the DI).
I've been looking at the Radial BigShot i/o true bypass instrument selector. Cheaper than the Bassbone and would probably do what I need. I need to switch between two basses, fretted and fretless. The fretless gets most of the action, but driving eighth notes work better on the fretted. I have just been muting and plugging in real quick, but the fretted is a little hotter. The Bigshot would hopefully take care of that.