• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Music man sound , no active electronic?

Not really a dumb question. At this time, I have two alternatives; 1) a B.C. Rich Virgin bass with a DiMarzio X2N-B pickup and 2) a Fender Reverse Jaguar. Both are not being made at this time, but if you can find one, they are good choices. Cheers. ;^D.
 
Ernie Ball USA SUB (some of them).
There is a Indonesian made Sterling SUB that is passive.
MTD Kingston had a passive version.
Fernandez Atlas.

Also there is a recent Ernie Ball BFR that is all passive and very light weight.
And a few that were made a while ago for GC that had both passive and active option.

Currently there is a short scale Sterling by MusicMan Stingray that is all passive. Also the USA Ernie Ball MusicMan Stingray short scale is passive.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. Cheese
The Harley Benton MB-4 and MB-5 imitate Music Man Stingrays and are passive. As far as the similarities in sound go, give them a listen on youtube and decide for yourself if they sound close enough to you.

I bought an MB-5 SBK just last week and with the stock strings it sounds Stingray-ish, but not quite there. I'm told the strings they ship with suck, though, so when I change them to the Elixirs I use on my Stingray 4 I expect it to sound more alike.
 
One possible option is the G&L Kiloton. Basically a FSO with one MFD humbucker in the Stingray position. It's an all passive bass.
Doesn't quite imitate the Stingray, but has more of the MFD humbucker thermonuclear weapon tone. A little less scoop and just a hell of a lot more of everything else. Steve Araujo does a review of it here:



This will get you in the ballpark, but without having to spend boutique-bass or signature-bass bucks to get it, even the MIA ones are < $2000.

L
 
Reverend Thundergun, passive, pure and potent.
I love mine.

(This guy goes a bit over the top, though.)
A Smoking Thundergun
If you've ever longed for a thud staff that combines the thunderous power of the classic bass sounds of yore with modern articulation and clarity, you might want to be under the gun--the Thundergun, that is! This beastly thud staff sounds as big as a banquet hall in Valhalla, but its voice also captures the nuances of your performance in hi-fi detail. And, it doesn't hurt that its offset body gives it an awesome retro-futuristic vibe!

Thor-Worthy Tonewoods
Speaking of the body, let's talk tonewoods. Like all Reverends, the Thundergun uses korina as its sonic building block. Korina shares many sound qualities with mahogany--warmth, punchiness, roundness, and evenness of response--but it has more harmonic content in the top end and is generally livelier all-around.

They pair this korina body with a five-piece neck made of korina and walnut, and this construction method gives it incredible stability, so you can rest assured that your setup will stay intact.

Pugnacious Pickups
The Thundergun has plenty of firepower thanks to its two gnarly pickups. The neck pickup is a Split Brick, and it sounds like a classic split-coil on steroids. As soon as my amp powered up, I felt compelled to play Sabbath, then to thump my way through a Motown tune, so it certainly evokes those classic tones. But, it has a bit more girth in the low-end, broader midrange response, and more chime in the trebles than an old-school split-coil. And, it also has a fantastically snappy, percussive attack. It's the sort of bass sound that's so solid you could build a house on it without sacrificing clarity or definition to do so.

Closer to the bridge, you'll find a Thick Brick humbucker, which has a bit of a brasher personality. Its low-end response is piano-like and full, its midrange is focused and biting, and the trebles have plenty of clank and snarl. In general, it has a bit more of a scooped sound, and it growls beautifully when you dig in. It presents a delightful contrast to the neck pickup, and it is supremely useful for cutting through a mix.

Best of all, you can blend the two pickups easily using the pickup pan knob. At the notch at twelve o'clock on the knob, both pickups are running full-bore. If you roll it all the way forward or backwards, you get just the neck or bridge. At all points in between, you hear a blend of the two. This simple tool gives you an extraordinary amount of tone-shaping ability. However, it's awfully hard to leave that point of equilibrium at noon, because it sounds so divine. You get the warmth and midrange punch of the neck pickup AND the booming lows and brashness of the bridge. The two sounds blend seamlessly, and you get full frequency response across the board AND exceptional clarity and articulation.

One Heck of a Neck
Instead of a chunky vintage-style neck, the fine folks at Reverend chose to outfit this puppy with a modern medium oval neck profile with a comfortable 1.65" nut width and a 12" radius. Reverend's medium oval profile is big enough to feel substantial but thin enough to feel fast and easy-to-play. The moderate nut width helps the neck hug the contours of your palm, and the 12" radius allows you to use a lower setup and bend strings more easily.


FB-IMG-1620428926056.jpg
 
Really like the stingray sound
I don’t like the battery
Any bass out there that sounds like a stingray but no battery?
Sorry about the dumb question
Benton has a passive stingray. It's pretty stinking decent, and pretty stinking cheap. And it's wired volume volume tone. One pickup.
 
Here's the video that convinced my to try a Kiloton. The tone is definitely of the passive hum bucking variety. My mains are stingray specials, the kiloton sounds more like the OG rays. But I love that slim jazz neck profile that's on the kilo. Last year I purchased a used kilo from a TB user. I mainly use it as my thrasher/jammer when I want the humbucking sound. It's also my main back up for gigs. Since it can switch between parallel and series I can make it sound close enough to a Ray or a P bass.

+1 for the Reverends as well. I only own the dub king myself, which is an awesome bass that could have cost way more... the Thundergun or the mercalli will do the hun bucking sound as well. However, IMO, the reverends have their own tonal flavor that aren't as close to the rays as the kiloton.

my 2 cents

 

Latest posts