OK so I did a bunch of research and learned that if you get a water-based stain, it typically reacts well with true oil. Most of the googling I did confirmed this. I ended up going with Home Depot Minwax water-based white stain. It’s it wipe on white stain You’ll find sitting on the shelf. Before I get to that though I ended up stripping the 1983 nitro body with Citrustrip. Wiped on a layer then enclosed it in a plastic bag over night. Used a metal scraper to remove the finish. Had to do 2 rounds then hand sanded w/ 80 / 220 / 800 grit before staining.
This is the stain.
View attachment 7089084
I cut up an old t-shirt. And started rubbing on the wood stain. To my surprise, this stuff was thicker than actual paint!! It did not rub off, rather left a thick bumpy coat. I immediately dropped a few f bombs, got some paint thinner and wiped it off back to almost the natural grain. Pissed, and determined, i immediately diluted the stain 3 parts water to one part stain, mixed it and tried again. Better but still too thick to show much grain. So, having only done about 1/4 of the body, i soaked a clean scrap of tshirt with water and rubbed as much of the stain off as i could and it resulted in what you see above. I had to work quickly to get it even, and its still not too even but good enough
At this point it was super flat and the stain was so thin that any sanding stated to show the natural wood, so i restained a couple spots and called it good on the stain.
Got some true oil from local sporting goods store hung the body on a laundry line and wiped on one coat with a clean tshirt scrap, in the direction of the grain. Let it dry overnight and was surprised to see that it was quite glossy when dry. The Minwax wipe on stain semi sealed the wood grain so the Tru oil didn’t soak in much but it did dry very hard. I put one more coat on, let dry a second night and then went to work with 0000 grit steel wool. Even that passed through the Tru oil and stain in one or two small spots accidentally. It’s a very very thin finish on this bass. But now that I’ve played it a week or two it’s starting to get smooth in areas and really look nice just from normal playing and wear and tear. Super happy with the results and though it’s not 100% Professional I love it.