• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

NBD - 50s P - Return It?

Send it back. You bought a new bass why should it be down to you to move neck,possibly move bridge etc.

It's a mass produced item,if the company care that little about the end product don't encourage them. I hear what folks are saying about if it feels right or sounds great but the OP paid good money,doesn't he deserve better ?

Half of the time you don't get better. It's like buying a harley half the time you get a pos and trade it in on a new bigger pos.
 
"That's what that model bridge is for!"

Great. They designed a bridge so they can be sloppy with positioning it :thumbsup:

Each saddle has multiple threads...it allows you to adjust spacing and string positioning by choosing different threads...it isn't a case of being sloppy. We are suggesting that choosing a different thread will quite likely put the strings in a spot the OP will prefer.
Works on mine..
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20170308_132326.jpg
    IMG_20170308_132326.jpg
    575.3 KB · Views: 94
I appreciate all the feedback.

A little history. I bought an Aerodyne about a year ago, and love the way it feels, love the J pickup, but it didn't quite nail the P tone. I replaced the pickups with Model PJs, and didn't like the sound so I put the stock pickups back on. I still played my trusty MIM P most often for the sound. I found myself thinking that I loved the feel of the Aerodyne so much, the same 7.25 radius would be perfect on a P. So I sold my old P and bought this 50s Precision. I played it for 3 hours at rehearsal tonight, and it feels nothing like the Aerodyne, and I shouldn't have expected it to with the wide neck. It's going to take some getting used to, the neck is even wider than my old P. It feels good, but my hand fatigued faster tonight than normal. But that will force me to relax a little more, and it will help my form. So it's all good in that respect.

The only negative, it was uncomfortable several times when I rolled from the D to the G with my little finger. The string is close enough to the edge that the side of the fingerboard would dig into my finger. Once again, that may help me with form, my finger was probably too flat. It sounds great, it feels great, it looks great. It's not a huge upgrade over my old P, probably not the extra $450 I put into it. But I absolutely love the color, and I always wanted to play a maple fretboard.

I did loosen the neck and try to move it. I didn't feel much movement, but I can see a small improvement after doing it. There isn't a noticeable difference in pickup output between strings, I'll probably tweak it a bit, but it's not the issue I was worried it might be.

Spirit: The intonation is as close as I expected, D and G strings right on, E and A a pinch sharp. So I don't see an issue like you mentioned.

Spidey - it's a 7.25 radius, so the pickups will be at more of an angle than on most.

I'm thinking I'll keep it. Thanks again, all!
 
And a couple people mentioned pickups not looking right. They're all a pinch higher than Fender's setup guide suggests, so I'll adjust those too after I lower the action a bit. Being a high radius, they'll be angled more than most pups. I'm also thinking flats, my 5 year old LaBella Jamesons is where Il'll start, it feels like heresy to have a 50s tribute P without flats. But the factory rounds have a growl that's a thing of beauty. Thanks again, folks.
 
My 50s classic was also misaligned. I couldn't mentally take it even though it sounded great. I upgraded the bridge with one with better string spacing potential and am now very happy. Strings out of line with pole pieces is apparently too much for me.
 
My 50s classic was also misaligned. I couldn't mentally take it even though it sounded great. I upgraded the bridge with one with better string spacing potential and am now very happy. Strings out of line with pole pieces is apparently too much for me.
I'm with ya man, I'm worried that might be an issue with me in the future. I did the same with my Aerodyne, put on a Hipshot type A (in black, of course) and that helped. And looks sharp on my black bass. But it just doesn't seem right to me to put a high-tech bridge on this P bass. But that's just me...
 
Loosen the neck, pull the stock toward the E string, and re-tighten the bolts. This isn't uncommon with bolt-on necks. If it makes you feel better, I have done it to much more expensive basses. If the thing plays great then I would just kiss it and love it and squeeze it and hug it and call it "George."


This. +100

But also don't forget you can adjust the string spacing at the bridge to be more even/to your liking.

It's all normal on that bass.
I have the same, in fiesta red. It had a blemish on the neck. Purely cosmetic... the thing played and sounded fantastic. I kept it.
 
"That's what that model bridge is for!"

Great. They designed a bridge so they can be sloppy with positioning it :thumbsup:


The bridge is not badly positioned. It cannot be. It's not drilled in place by one person that can screw it up. They're all placed at the exact same spot in every single bass body. That's mass production for you.

The 'issue' here is so minimal I'm surprised anybody talks about sending it back. It's like returning your new car because one tire is a little flat.
 
Looks fine to me, you seem to have the same space between the strings, but I think spacing is middle of the string to middle of the string. Might need a little neck adjustment as mentioned, then just move the G and E strings over a thread or two, it is too wide at the bridge. A little adjustment goes a long way. These things are CNC'd and such not much room for error, no reason to return it.
 
The bridge is not badly positioned. It cannot be. It's not drilled in place by one person that can screw it up. They're all placed at the exact same spot in every single bass body. That's mass production for you.

The 'issue' here is so minimal I'm surprised anybody talks about sending it back. It's like returning your new car because one tire is a little flat.
It's that minimal to the OP he took photos and posted here about it.
 
There are some good suggestions in here on ways that might remedy your issue but if you aren't satisfied with it right out of the box I would send it back. The 50's P IMO is a not as talked about gem in the Fender line. Got mine new for $599 from a local music store. The owner bought it for himself but decided not to keep it. I have never played a neck as chunky but there's something about it that makes me like it. It is uncomfortable for me to play in certain spots but that's more due to my poor technique!