• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

NBD, with or with out pickguard?

With or without?

  • With

    Votes: 149 55.6%
  • Without

    Votes: 119 44.4%

  • Total voters
    268
Silly question- has anybody ever tried just high end 3M tape under the pickgaurd and ditch putting screws into the body?

This way you can always convert it to whatever tastes suit you with no worries.
That’s exactly what I did for my last Alien Audio Constellation. Works great and allows a subsequent owner the choice of ditching the pickguard and not having a bunch of screw holes detracting from the appearance of the bass.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PennyroyalWe
The floating control plate always makes me laugh.
I'd simply go with a black pickguard and a black control plate just so it doesn't look all the other Affinity Jazz basses out there.
20200626-020449.jpg
 
Silly question- has anybody ever tried just high end 3M tape under the pickgaurd and ditch putting screws into the body?

This way you can always convert it to whatever tastes suit you with no worries.

Yes, that's exactly what I did with my Dingwall Afterburner. The model is not available with a pickguard, so I outlined one to my liking, and taped it to the body. If I ever sell it (doubtful) or change my mind (just as doubtful), it should be relatively easy to remove it, and leave no mark on the body.

dw.jpg


Silly question: why is dust nearly invisible to the naked eye, but sticks out SO MUCH in pictures?
 
Yes, that's exactly what I did with my Dingwall Afterburner. The model is not available with a pickguard, so I outlined one to my liking, and taped it to the body. If I ever sell it (doubtful) or change my mind (just as doubtful), it should be relatively easy to remove it, and leave no mark on the body.

View attachment 3881671

Silly question: why is dust nearly invisible to the naked eye, but sticks out SO MUCH in pictures?
That looks awesome!

I’m surprised that manufactures and builders are not using that method of attachment.
 
That looks awesome!

The only thing that's not perfect is that the pickguard is cut at a 90° angle around the neck, but the neck heel rises gradually. So there's a mismatch there. Sheldon Dingwall came up with a proposal/recommendation on how to angle the pickguard to make a perfect match, but alas it was a bit too late, and by the time I got his idea my luthier had already cut the material. You can kind of see what I mean with that:
20200626_131038.jpg

Of course you can only notice if you're looking for it.

Back to the thread's topic: if your bass has already drilled holes, don't you even dream of playing around without a pickguard. All the tone will leak from the naked holes, and you will have 80 dead spots (20 frets times 4 strings). Plus the mojo will slowly evaporate from the body into the surrounding air, which will likely be absorbed by the rest of the band. And everyone knows how much we bass players hate the rest of the band having better mojo than us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PennyroyalWe