• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Need help setting someone straight - your POV please

The decline of live music is hardly the fault of freebies, or at least that's only a fraction of the reason. The real reasons which make up the bulk of that are DUI laws, and VASTLY increased options for high quality home entertainment.
 
The decline of live music is hardly the fault of freebies, or at least that's only a fraction of the reason. The real reasons which make up the bulk of that are DUI laws, and VASTLY increased options for high quality home entertainment.
Agree about the DUI laws, and you can add the proliferation of gambling 'boats' to the mix as well.
 
While not so much a part of this thread but this situation was along these same lines:

My wife and I went to a couple's house because they were having a block party. We arrived late so got the tail end of folks sitting under easy-ups and having a beer and talking. Our friend's husband introduced us and said "Irma (my wife) is a great singer. You ought hear her sing. Her voice is like Linda Ronstadt's." So a couple of the neighbors said "Really? Let's hear you sing something". Of course there was no music, no musicians, no DJ, or anything else for accompaniment.

I turned to her and told her in Spanish so most of them wouldn't understand: "You're not a novelty act for their entertainment. These people have absolutely no knowledge or appreciation for music or your talent. AND nobody is giving you money to be a performing monkey for their amusement." She got the point and told them that she cannot sing unless there is a band backing her up.

Unfortunately, playing for free puts us into that category of being a performing monkey for people's amusement.
Obviously I wasn't there, so I don't have the full effect. As I understand it, you bragged on your wife's singing voice. The hosts and guests were intrigued and asked to hear her sing, and you shut it down. This is quite a different situation than the OP presented. You guys were kind of rude. Not rude to the point I wouldn't ask you over again but I wouldn't be interested in anyone's singing voice or to hear about it anymore.
 
Obviously I wasn't there, so I don't have the full effect. As I understand it, you bragged on your wife's singing voice. The hosts and guests were intrigued and asked to hear her sing, and you shut it down. This is quite a different situation than the OP presented. You guys were kind of rude. Not rude to the point I wouldn't ask you over again but I wouldn't be interested in anyone's singing voice or to hear about it anymore.

No...you read it wrong...I did not brag on my wife's singing voice. The person who invited us introduced us to their neighbors and made mention of my wife's singing voice. The woman leading the charge in wanting my wife to sing struck me as someone who was not really intrigued with wanting to hear her sing. It was also very obvious for various reasons that she was not a lover of the arts or talent; she was a pompous ass...I can see them a mile away.

There are people out there who appreciate talent and are edified by music while others can take it or leave it. That was the atmosphere in that situation. Likewise, I don't sit in with anyone unless 1) I am asked to and 2) if I have my own bass with me. I don't want anyone touching my gear if I don't know them and I would not expect anyone to make an exception with me. It's their gig; not mine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ELG60
I love to play and love crowds, who doesn't!? I have a rule that has been agreed upon by the 4 if us. We do 2 "worth while " free benefits a year. It's up to me to make sure the need for free is legit. We come from all over the state and driving / gas is now an issue as it should be.

Our time, load in and load out are worth something as well. We love to play and yes, it's fun. But, there is also the work aspect that's needs to be considered. Playing is the fun, everything else is work deserving compensation. Just my opinion.

Not exactly relevant but. Over the past year I couldn't figure out why our gigs were going down. I made inquires and found out why. Beer n burger bands were taking some control of the venue's we had played for years. Almost playing for nothing. Then one day I get a phone call from a long time venue that we had seemingly lost. Bruce, Don, you have a minute? Yes sir I do, what's up? Uh, we haven't had you guys play for about 6 months. I would like to have you back in 2 weeks if possible?

I asked him the necessary question. Why haven't we been?? Well, I went on the cheap. But, we got what we paid for. Crowds were dwindling and I'm starting to lose my ass. People were constantly asking where you guys were? I told them you were busy, I lied.

Well, we are busy I said but, I don't like losing venue's like yours by band(s) backdooring us. Don: are you busy in 2 weeks? I will look, hold on. No, it's the only weekend we have open for the next month. If you want us we are available. So, playing for free is alive and well and hurting us long time working bands. Like it or not, I think it's a sign of the times.
 
.........Our time, load in and load out are worth something as well. We love to play and yes, it's fun. But, there is also the work aspect that's needs to be considered. Playing is the fun, everything else is work deserving compensation. Just my opinion.......
Good point, like the old saying...we play for free but we DO charge for moving all of this equipment.
 
No...you read it wrong...I did not brag on my wife's singing voice. The person who invited us introduced us to their neighbors and made mention of my wife's singing voice. The woman leading the charge in wanting my wife to sing struck me as someone who was not really intrigued with wanting to hear her sing. It was also very obvious for various reasons that she was not a lover of the arts or talent; she was a pompous ass...I can see them a mile away.

There are people out there who appreciate talent and are edified by music while others can take it or leave it. That was the atmosphere in that situation. Likewise, I don't sit in with anyone unless 1) I am asked to and 2) if I have my own bass with me. I don't want anyone touching my gear if I don't know them and I would not expect anyone to make an exception with me. It's their gig; not mine.
Apologies. I hope I didn't offend, it wasn't my purpose.
 
OK trying for brevity here but I will probably fail. I'm writing because I'm super frustrated with a friend who on one topic has always been clueless and I thought maybe some of you could assist.

I'm an amateur player in a couple of bands. Many years ago I was taking lessons while I was in a jazz standards band that played small events from time to time. I asked my teacher what we should be charging and he was adamant that we accept no less than union scale. The idea was that giving it away or playing for cheap is terrible for working musicians. I have since heard the same thing from many people who make some or all of their living as musicians. And I've quit bands after playing free gigs (for charity, for example) where everyone else gets paid - the florists, the caterers, the bartenders, the venue, etc. I don't mind playing a charity gig for free as long as everyone else is giving it away too. Otherwise, music ain't free.

My BEST friend, oldest friend, plays drums and we have been playing together for many years, and he loves playing as I do, but he's always willing to play for free and grudgingly will get us gigs that pay $100 a guy, whatever. (The last bar gig I played, with a different band, we all agreed to donate the proceeds to charity... none of us needs $100.)

OK so my drummer pal just told me he wants to play Saturday night at the end of the month at a private party for people who want to have a blow out party before they do a "massive reno" (his words) on their house. And he's going to play for free but will "try" to get us $100. For my $100 I will have to haul, set up, and tear down not only my bass rig but a PA and mics on Saturday night. I'll have help at the venue but ultimately will be loading and unloading. Let's not get into how bad the traffic in Toronto is... especially on Saturday night.

I'm only going to quote one of his texts (and this is a guy I have known for 49 years:

"Watch how quickly I jump at any chance to play live and I'm lugging a poopieload more gear than u...If I get some $ out of it great but I'm not a jobber and I'm not a pro by a long shot so I don't have the same attitude about playing music as u...it's kinda sad"
(he does go on to insult me multiple times, which IS what's sad to me because we are such good friends and it's not like I haven't told him what I think many times).

Anyway, what do you fellow low-enders think?

Don't play with him anymore. And you can tell him I said this: Stop playing music. STOP. These gigs could have gone to pros who need the work, and you come in and work for free. The fact that he and others like them do what they do is why music is such a hard thing to make a living at.

Union scale, though . . . . very few gigs that I have done have been regulated in this way. I usually get paid a base rate (each band is different) and then extra for overtime and travel.