• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Need opinions and guidance building a space elevator.

I actually did go to liftport.com, and browsed through the site looking for some additional information in response to my question. I went to the "Lunar elevator" tab of the site, and clicked the "Why does it matter?" link. This is what it says, quoted in its entirety:

Before we can build Earth’s Elevator, we’ll need to build one on the Moon. It is significantly easier, and much much cheaper. Importantly - we can build it with current technology – in about eight years. To meet our target date, we need to complete a 1-year Feasibility Study, beginning next year. That will cost $3 million.

Just to be sure I wasn't missing something, I looked through all of the other links under the "Lunar Elevator" tab, but other than a couple of cursory paragraphs and a link to the Wikipedia article, there is no additional information to be found.

So where is the technical information? Honestly, I was trying to give you the benefit of the doubt and keep an open mind, but that site is a complete joke.

Edit: I just found the "downloads" section of the site, and saw that is a "Business" section, with subcategories for Cost/Benefits, Finance/Accounting, and Operations/Management section of the site. "A ha," though I, "this must be where I will find the projections for all of the alleged cost savings." I clicked the links, fully prepared to be dazzled, or at the very least, informed, but every link has the same message: "This category doesn't have any files yet." Wow.

Hey thanks for going to the site. Yes, it is still in process, the team kinda shrunk eight years ago, and so Michael has been doing things kinda by himself. The team is coming back together, and of course is gathering new personnel. The site is also newly put together, so consider. Also, please remember the kickstarter campaign started with a goal of 8K, so the level of interest and support has been overwhelming I'm sure. If you really want some information email somebody, or post directly to Michelle C. (one of the site administrators)on the forum. Thanks again.
 
I actually did go to liftport.com, and browsed through the site looking for some additional information in response to my question. I went to the "Lunar elevator" tab of the site, and clicked the "Why does it matter?" link. This is what it says, quoted in its entirety:

Before we can build Earth’s Elevator, we’ll need to build one on the Moon. It is significantly easier, and much much cheaper. Importantly - we can build it with current technology – in about eight years. To meet our target date, we need to complete a 1-year Feasibility Study, beginning next year. That will cost $3 million.

Just to be sure I wasn't missing something, I looked through all of the other links under the "Lunar Elevator" tab, but other than a couple of cursory paragraphs and a link to the Wikipedia article, there is no additional information to be found.

So where is the technical information? Honestly, I was trying to give you the benefit of the doubt and keep an open mind, but that site is a complete joke.

Edit: I just found the "downloads" section of the site, and saw that is a "Business" section, with subcategories for Cost/Benefits, Finance/Accounting, and Operations/Management section of the site. "A ha," though I, "this must be where I will find the projections for all of the alleged cost savings." I clicked the links, fully prepared to be dazzled, or at the very least, informed, but every link has the same message: "This category doesn't have any files yet." Wow.

I read that site top to bottom three times thinking I must be missing something, all these benefits were spelled out, all my questions were answered, and I was just an idiot. Read like the ramblings of a loon to me. The Inuits would have sent this guy out to sea on a piece of ice.
 
I read that site top to bottom three times thinking I must be missing something, all these benefits were spelled out, all my questions were answered, and I was just an idiot. Read like the ramblings of a loon to me. The Inuits would have sent this guy out to sea on a piece of ice.

Hey thanks for at least going to the site. As previously mentioned, it is still being fleshed out. And as a side note, do you know one of the definitions used to define insanity? It is, not producing something of use to society. What would someone have said about the, "ramblings" of Einstein were he born ten year years earlier? Michael Laine is not a loon, or a scam artist, though he may be proposing a dream bigger than humanly possible right now. While you were on the site, reading closely, did you see how many members there are? People with degrees, students who are going to MIT, folks who actually work in the fields you'd think applicable to this project, all ready to volunteer money, time, effort, whatever they can. Yea, they all could be scam artists, or loons too I suppose. I don't think so, as there are too many people, "gathered", there who would know better if this wasn't very worthwhile.
 
Hey thanks for at least going to the site. As previously mentioned, it is still being fleshed out. And as a side note, do you know one of the definitions used to define insanity? It is, not producing something of use to society. What would someone have said about the, "ramblings" of Einstein were he born ten year years earlier? Michael Laine is not a loon, or a scam artist, though he may be proposing a dream bigger than humanly possible right now. While you were on the site, reading closely, did you see how many members there are? People with degrees, students who are going to MIT, folks who actually work in the fields you'd think applicable to this project, all ready to volunteer money, time, effort, whatever they can. Yea, they all could be scam artists, or loons too I suppose. I don't think so, as there are too many people, "gathered", there who would know better if this wasn't very worthwhile.

You didn't used to post on TB under the name "Muzique Fann" did you? This thread is starting to remind me a lot of this one: http://www.talkbass.com/forum/f69/if-you-only-had-00-invest-226799/ (for those with Lobby access).

I don't suppose you are going to tell investors to go "long and strong" with this investment?
 
You didn't used to post on TB under the name "Muzique Fann" did you? This thread is starting to remind me a lot of this one: http://www.talkbass.com/forum/f69/if-you-only-had-00-invest-226799/ (for those with Lobby access).

I don't suppose you are going to tell investors to go "long and strong" with this investment?

I've always been mcglyph. Who the heck wants to be muzique fan? Sounds like what might be found in a Wurlitzer.

I looked at the thread, without seeing any connection. Perhaps you could spell it out?
 
I've always been mcglyph. Who the heck wants to be muzique fan? Sounds like what might be found in a Wurlitzer.

I looked at the thread, without seeing any connection. Perhaps you could spell it out?

It might be worth you taking the time to read through all 25 pages. I think there is a lot of valuable information that you could learn from that thread about how to spot scams etc. You may well want to check out how the Nevada Mining Corporation is doing these days as well (since there havn't been updates on that thread for some time). Suffice to say, the investors are not happy.
 
It might be worth you taking the time to read through all 25 pages. I think there is a lot of valuable information that you could learn from that thread about how to spot scams etc. You may well want to check out how the Nevada Mining Corporation is doing these days as well (since there havn't been updates on that thread for some time). Suffice to say, the investors are not happy.

Oh ok. So let's be clear you think the project is a scam?
I'm going to assume this. So here is what I'm thinking.
I looked at the thread. Looking at the content of the thread you are currently reading, see I believe there is no relationship. If you still see one, read this thread (the space elevator one), if you still see one, and insist..I'm going to put you in the third category. It's labeled, "Those who are not actually paying Attention". The other categories are, "Paying Attention and Skeptic", and, "Paying Attention seeker". Unfortunately, this thread has much of the, "paying...skeptic" group. Takes all kinds I guess.
 
Presumably, the OP is familiar with the kind of person he's giving money to: [Invalid or Expired Link Removed]

That's right, the Stage of Washington already entered into a cosnent Order with the CEO and Company because they admitted to illegally offering securities (ie getting investors) in Washington. It appears this Kickstarter is just another way of obtaining funds without the illegal issue of securities in the company. He also admitted to engaging in fraud:

"In connection with the offer or sale of the said securities Liftport, Inc., violated RCW 21.20.010 because, as set forth in the Tentative Findings of Fact, Respondent made misstatements of material fact or omitted to state material facts necessary in order to make the statements made, in light of circumstances under which they were made, not misleading and/or engaged in acts and practices that operated as a fraud or deceit."

Do I think its a scam? All signs point to yes.
 
Presumably, the OP is familiar with the kind of person he's giving money to: [Invalid or Expired Link Removed]

Very interesting. According to the consent order, Laine collected $117,542 from investors between June 2003 and March 2006.

The Consent Order also notes that, "As early as 2004 the Liftport website contained a section ... which stated, 'Money: At present, Liftport, Inc. is in the early start-up stages, and like any start-up, has strong financial needs in order to achieve our goal of building the Space Elevator."

According to mcglyph:

Yes, it is still in process, the team kinda shrunk eight years ago, and so Michael has been doing things kinda by himself.

According to the Consent Order, the Liftport website projected in 2004 that Liftport would develop and build an operation space elevator by 2018. mcglyph, why did the team "kinda shrink" in 2004, at the same time Laine was using a projected operation date of 2018 to solicit over $100,000 money from investors? Given that the website was indicating that the company was a start-up at that time, but projecting a 2018 operation date, should it not have been growing, rather than shrinking?

Here's another interesting fact from the Consent Order: "The offering materials Liftport provided to potential investors in connection with the offering did not include financial statements, a detailed use of proceeds, projected costs to develop and build the space elevator, general risk factors related to the space technology, and specific risk factors related to space elevator production." This is exactly the same type of information that I searched for, but found missing, at the liftport.com website.
 
Basically, this boils down to a guy who got pinged for fraudulently trying to raise capital via a share issue (when at least in theory the investors would have got something back) now finding another avenue to do it through kickstarter and social media. However, because funds dondated through Kickstarter creates no legal accountability, eh can do whatever he likes with them and you would have no standing to sue (nor would any regulator). Quite a clever way to separate fools from their money.
 
Marlat said:
Basically, this boils down to a guy who got pinged for fraudulently trying to raise capital via a share issue (when at least in theory the investors would have got something back) now finding another avenue to do it through kickstarter and social media. However, because funds dondated through Kickstarter creates no legal accountability, eh can do whatever he likes with them and you would have no standing to sue (nor would any regulator). Quite a clever way to separate fools from their money.

Nearly 400 posts in....hopefully mcglyph will finally get it that we ain't suckers :)
 
Well yeah, of course I know about the case. And the people and organizations which are going to be supporting this project do as well. Judging from all the stuff coming from you guys I know you don't think this world is without all kinds of grey areas between the black and white lines you are currently insisting on! I'm not even going to point out
the forty seven people which changed the world either for the better or just gave us all these things which made our lives easier, while killing their competition, selling illegal shares, blowing up other people's oil wells, back trading, plain out stealing, etc.
Should we all aspire to greatness by doing it their way? Of course not, yet, the fact remains, were it not for these realities our world would look very different. Tesla's lab was destroyed by his competition to keep him from moving forward with this ideas! Ideas which really by some still are not even recognized as his. It really boils down to all of you just painting with flimsy noodles. If you don't believe in the project dont. The scam screaming is tiresome. The horse is beaten.
 
Tesla's lab was destroyed by his competition to keep him from moving forward with this ideas! Ideas which really by some still are not even recognized as his. It really boils down to all of you just painting with flimsy noodles. If you don't believe in the project dont. The scam screaming is tiresome. The horse is beaten.

Perhaps had that not occured we'd have had a space elevator decades ago...

And youre painting with the rigid pre-cooked ones? No thanks.
 
Well yeah, of course I know about the case. And the people and organizations which are going to be supporting this project do as well. Judging from all the stuff coming from you guys I know you don't think this world is without all kinds of grey areas between the black and white lines you are currently insisting on! I'm not even going to point out
the forty seven people which changed the world either for the better or just gave us all these things which made our lives easier, while killing their competition, selling illegal shares, blowing up other people's oil wells, back trading, plain out stealing, etc.
Should we all aspire to greatness by doing it their way? Of course not, yet, the fact remains, were it not for these realities our world would look very different. Tesla's lab was destroyed by his competition to keep him from moving forward with this ideas! Ideas which really by some still are not even recognized as his. It really boils down to all of you just painting with flimsy noodles. If you don't believe in the project dont. The scam screaming is tiresome. The horse is beaten.
So you're saying defrauding potential investors is okay if the end is justified?
 

Latest posts