• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

New Player- Are Lessons "Worth It"?

Short answer Yes, direction and feedback. If you don't have good chemistry with the teacher you can always try a different one. It doesn't have to be a long term commitment. (Perhaps you can hop in a free trial lesson?)

And simultaneously you can use your tab notions and online resources to practice, have fun and pick a thing or two with the bass for free. Some examples:

https://www.youtube.com/user/devinebass (Scott's Bass Lessons)
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCTLM0C5Acp-0xi4ZEb-mSQg (Real Bass Lessons)
[Invalid or Expired Link Removed] (Talking Bass)
 
No, but I don't make assumptions, either. ;)
Come on, everyone makes assumptions. ;) Regardless, I didn’t suggest that there are no competent teachers at GC - but that is not where I would direct anyone looking for a teacher. If others think that GC is a great place to find a teacher then they are free to make their recommendations accordingly. :)
 
I found my drum teacher at GC. I took lessons there for a couple months. He was good, the setup at GC was not. Plus, it was a lot of money. He decided to strike out on his own, and I was his first private student. He comes over once a week. I have two kits in the garage. He’s a great drummer and a great instructor. We have a good time. I’d be better, if I practiced more. I’m on the road a lot, so I bring my practice pad. I had a bass teacher for awhile, but the C19 sort of knocked that out. I’ve been concentrating on the drums more, anyway.
 
Great bassists typically have great ears; they can hear and read far more than they are usually asked to play - with impeccable time.

If you are already capable of thinking in terms of "the cycle, " and have impeccable time, a teacher can help by tailoring your lessons based on you, as an individual, and your particular areas of strength and weakness. And a teacher can offer insights into time and applying theory while playing that can be difficult to obtain by yourself.
 
Yes. Depends on the teacher to some extent, but for a new player, instruction is a good thing. When I was starting out in my mid-30s I took lessons for a couple of years, and it definitely helped. As with anything, though, you get out what you put in, so if you don't do the work between lessons, it's not going to do much for you.
 
Hi All,

Just wondering if you think bass lessons are "worth it" for a new player.

I know how to read tabs and have watched some things on YouTube and knew how to read music as a teenager (it's been years so I'm pretty rusty). I only reference this because while I'm completely new to bass and haven't tried to play music in years I do have at least a foundation to start with even if it's very small.

Just wondering for the more experienced people here if you felt like lessons helped or hurt your playing? Should I be looking for anything in particular from a teacher? The Guitar Center near me is having a sale on lessons so I'm tempted to give it a shot.

Convincing myself to practice doesn't seem to be an issue- Just wondering if I'm f-ing up by learning on my own as it isn't really formal training and I have wondered what bad habits I may be inadvertently forming. Also wondering if having a lesson once every few weeks would accelerate the learning process...

Thanks!
the true answer to your question is this....everyone is different..lessons may or may not be "worth it" to you..as you put it.......................it all depends on your intent...motivation...and effort.......................mental capacity is different for everyone..I can hire someone to teach me how to water ski...but I can also have a lot of fun just going out there and doing it myself.....just depends on what you want..there are those who have become great players and have never taken a lesson and there are those who have been "school boys" and are quite dull and ordinary..its you own personal zest that makes life experiences great..
 
A question you may want to ask yourself is whether you like being a student. So are lessons worth it? Teachers can do something that we often will avoid: doing something new or unfamiliar. When we practice on our own, we may be reluctant to push ourselves.

After working at a music store for seven years, I observed all of the different teaching styles.

Lock, stock, stick to the book teachers: you will play out of the Mel Bay book page by page week by week. You are the student, and you will follow the teacher.

Teach you what you want to know teachers: you can bring songs to them, and they will tab it out for you. Of course they will also do the instructional book path if you want.

The constructivist: they will show you mostly things they know but are lacking on the "by the book" stuff. But they are usually very nice because they have to be.

The Philosopher: this teacher will just talk to you the whole lesson while you hold your guitar. Sometimes the talk will be about playing music, but sometimes it will just be stories from their own lives.

The Smoker/Philosopher: Same as philosopher except you will probably be standing outside while the teacher smokes and you listen. Other philosophers will surely join.

The late guy or gal: they will always be late and will try to reschedule often. They will also have to smoke after they arrive late for your lesson.

There are other sub-species of teachers out there, but the above were the most common. Consider the creepy teacher, flirt with mom teacher, too much cologne teacher, emotionally unavailable teacher, make you practice in the room while they smoke teacher, etc.

I would suggest trying to eavesdrop on some teacher's lessons to see what goes on. Some studios are set up where you can kind of linger in the hallway and hear what is happening.

But as an adult, it is sometimes easier to communicate what you want from a teacher. Maybe you want to learn a little more about walking bass lines. You could take lessons from a guitar teacher that can play chords over your lines. I heard that one a lot.

Taking bass lessons with a drum teacher might be interesting.
 
Regardless, I didn’t suggest that there are no competent teachers at GC

Of course you did. You inferred that he wouldn't find a competent teacher at GC. Per your first post....."You had the "feeling" that he wouldn't find the "right teacher at GC." What else would be your meaning? He would only find the "wrong teacher" at GC.?

I think I have made my point. I don't intend to go back and forth with you ad nauseam in this thread.

Sometimes, I believe, that we need not to be so negative in our responses to newcomers that come to TB asking for advise. Without knowing more about their situation or even where they are from. Not every GC store is full of incompetents. No one ever knows what to expect at their local music store (including GC) until they experience it themselves. How does a beginner bass player know if his new teacher is any good or not unless he actually takes lessons from them? What would the new bass player use to compare?
 
Last edited:
Hi All,

Just wondering if you think bass lessons are "worth it" for a new player.

I know how to read tabs and have watched some things on YouTube and knew how to read music as a teenager (it's been years so I'm pretty rusty). I only reference this because while I'm completely new to bass and haven't tried to play music in years I do have at least a foundation to start with even if it's very small.

Just wondering for the more experienced people here if you felt like lessons helped or hurt your playing? Should I be looking for anything in particular from a teacher? The Guitar Center near me is having a sale on lessons so I'm tempted to give it a shot.

Convincing myself to practice doesn't seem to be an issue- Just wondering if I'm f-ing up by learning on my own as it isn't really formal training and I have wondered what bad habits I may be inadvertently forming. Also wondering if having a lesson once every few weeks would accelerate the learning process...

Thanks!
Experienced player and lessons are still worth it for me.
 
Hi All,

Just wondering if you think bass lessons are "worth it" for a new player.

I know how to read tabs and have watched some things on YouTube and knew how to read music as a teenager (it's been years so I'm pretty rusty). I only reference this because while I'm completely new to bass and haven't tried to play music in years I do have at least a foundation to start with even if it's very small.

Just wondering for the more experienced people here if you felt like lessons helped or hurt your playing? Should I be looking for anything in particular from a teacher? The Guitar Center near me is having a sale on lessons so I'm tempted to give it a shot.

Convincing myself to practice doesn't seem to be an issue- Just wondering if I'm f-ing up by learning on my own as it isn't really formal training and I have wondered what bad habits I may be inadvertently forming. Also wondering if having a lesson once every few weeks would accelerate the learning process...

Thanks!

Yes, lessons are definitely worth it -- with the right teacher. Not GC. Do some research to find a teacher who cares about you and your progress. Lessons could be either in-person or on-line.
 
Honestly if you're new to bass but not music you have everything you need. I would go with seeing one every few weeks to get some perspective but if you already know how to read music and you can carry your practice habits from your old instrument then it's really just a matter of learning the techniques. You're not a teen so you should be ok. What was your old instrument?
 
Great bassists typically have great ears; they can hear and read far more than they are usually asked to play - with impeccable time.

If you are already capable of thinking in terms of "the cycle, " and have impeccable time, a teacher can help by tailoring your lessons based on you, as an individual, and your particular areas of strength and weakness. And a teacher can offer insights into time and applying theory while playing that can be difficult to obtain by yourself.
What cycle?
 
I've been a beginner for over 10yrs now because I haven't had lessons. If time would allow me to take them I would in a heartbeat! I learn what I can but for me paying someone to hold me accountable would bring me up a few levels, maybe when I retire I'll get to goto school!
 
Come on, everyone makes assumptions. ;) Regardless, I didn’t suggest that there are no competent teachers at GC - but that is not where I would direct anyone looking for a teacher. If others think that GC is a great place to find a teacher then they are free to make their recommendations accordingly. :)
I think somebody is just looking for a fight.

I agree with you 100%, GC wouldn't be where I would start. I got incredibly lucky twice starting out in the 70's. I just went to the local music store and lucked into a really good teacher. He left, and I was handed over to another teacher who was also really good. Then I went to college and had some exceptional teachers.

But, I've taught at music stores and my experience is that the best and the brightest, with some notable exceptions, don't teach there [I said exceptions, no need for anyone to post examples]. They just don't pay enough. A skilled teacher can make as much or more on their own with far fewer students.

Just my 2 cents.