• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Double Bass New York Phil.

FYI. The last time Charlie Nilles was the only person in the finals. Everyone voted yes except for the conductor. I doubt Levinson was a reason for the lack of hiring. However they did hire a new executive director so that may change how the New York Phil operates quite a bit.
 
Ahhhh...the sad thing is, Charlie could probably wipe the floor with half the section...but he's not good enough for the conductor. I think Cleveland had a similar situation with their audition. I wonder what would happen if current members had to re-audition for their spots? The bar seems to be set too high.
 
The only similarity between the circumstances of the two auditions was the resulting no-hire, which is unfortunate in itself. It's not my impression that the panel at the last Cleveland audition thought the final candidates in their last audition were in any way unqualified.
 
I think it is rather naive to assume any one player could "wipe the floor" of any bass section. Unfortunately, I have seen comments of this nature before and just took it with no regard. From my experience in this business, I can safely assume that one who makes such a comment has never played in a quality group.

As for Cleveland, somehow, by the power of some unseen cosmic force, the three finalists didn't have that spark at the right moment. With that being said, I do like how the conductor hears every player from start to finish.
 
It is very easy to hire. Just need a good short list that covers a range of playing styles. There is no reason for there not to be a hire except if the orchestra is not financially ready to hire. In that case there should be no audition. A long list is also a way orchestras weed out players that are not prepared for the job. This usually does not work.