MORE ALIKE THAN DIFFERENT.....HOW TO CHOOSE.
So, as you may have noticed, I've been a bit enamored of the little TC BAM200 into the MAS 16.
That hasn't changed, BUT. I've been feeling a little guilty about neglecting my old friend, The Genzler Acoustic Pro Gollihur model. So I hooked them both up with an A/B switch and did a 'shootout'.
Bottom Line: They sound a lot more alike than different. So why choose one over the other?
There is a difference in size and weight of about 10 pounds. So IF you are going to just run a piezo straight into one or the other the BAM/MAS is a much easier schlep.
If you wish to blend a mic and a piezo the difference narrows (a little bit) since the BAM will require an external blending pre-amp. I use a Zoom A3 which, although it is not intuitive, has a lot of available features and allows me to use it as a footswitch to switch between two different settings - for example, one setting for pizz and one for arco. This setup requires the extra piece of equipment (the pre-amp) and at least one extra cable. Still, the total weight is less than the Genzler - approximately 20 pounds (+ gig bag) VS 27 pounds for the Genzler.
If your are JUST going to use a mic, the Genzler allows you to pack 1 mic, 1 XLR cable and 1 power cord and you're all set. If you are going to blend a piezo just add 1 instrument cable.
IF (and this may be unusual, but I will be doing it one night this week), you are going to have a singer, or another instrumentalist who would like to be miced, the Genzler can act as a PA as well as your bass amp. It also has reverb and chorus (on both channels) so it is rather vocal-friendly. (My Zoom Pre could also accommodate a singers microphone AND had reverb, but again not as intuitive or simple).
So I guess I'm suffering from an excess of options. Not really a bad thing in terms of backup, and I really like all the gear so much that I can't see selling any of it - even though it is somewhat redundant.
Here is a picture of the two rigs. If I get ambitious I may add a sound recording comparing the two sometime.
View attachment 3427192