• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Not sure what to make of this statement.

I've recently started working with a drummer that "brought me in" to his group of two guitarists.
At the second jam, I was talking instruments with one of the guitarists, who has an affinity for 70s Asian knockoffs (lawsuit guitars, etc.). That's cool - I'm not a gear snob. When I started talking modestly about my collection (which he already hinted at having an American bias), this guy comes out with "Well, you know people who buy expensive instruments are compensating for their lack of ability", with a smirk on his face.
I was so amazed by his statement that I encouraged him to repeat it again... and he did! I played it off like it didn't bother me but it seemed RIDICULOUSLY passive-aggressive, and honestly, the drummer and I are playing at a higher level.
I mentioned a few reasons why I agree and disagree with what he said, but it still came across as a personal attack in the end.
I'm not worried about losing the drummer because he said he's been looking for a bassist like me for years.
I guess I'm kinda venting, but I'm on the fence with this guitarist now after his barbed statements. Very odd.
Have you run into anything similar?
upload_2023-4-18_9-3-40.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: TN WOODMAN
A lot of people saying he's just trying to be funny. That may be, but when a guy says something that could be taken wrong by someone they don't really know, it's social ineptitude or worse. In my band, we rip on each other all the time, but we all know it's in fun. None of us would say the things we do to someone we just met.
 
Who's sensitive? I said: "Fill your boots". I'm okay with people being wrong about me. This ain't my first rodeo.
Why are you over reacting?
-see, this is my point to your defense of said guitarist being an ass. The OP isn't reacting weird at all when someone he doesn't know talk to him like a jerk. It's up to us to all to relate to others if we want to be treated reasonably. You are making my point for me- you could have just let it go, because my humor you might not get, right? Nobody likes to be talked to nasty by strangers. And that's it.
Especially when you are in a room trying to be creative with them....
 
Why are you over reacting?
-see, this is my point to your defense of said guitarist being an ass. The OP isn't reacting weird at all when someone he doesn't know talk to him like a jerk. It's up to us to all to relate to others if we want to be treated reasonably. You are making my point for me- you could have just let it go, because my humor you might not get, right? Nobody likes to be talked to nasty by strangers. And that's it.
Especially when you are in a room trying to be creative with them....

My issue is with you assuming my "over-reacting". I'm not. I'm sitting here, very calmly, working on my music.

There was no "over-reaction". You're making that up, strawman(ning) an argument which doesn't exist. I could not possibly care less what someone says about me on some forum; except when they mis-represent me, which is what you're doing.

I say again: enjoy yourself, but stop assuming you know the first thing about how I'm reacting.
 
My issue is with you assuming my "over-reacting". I'm not. I'm sitting here, very calmly, working on my music.

There was no "over-reaction". You're making that up, strawman(ning) an argument which doesn't exist. I could not possibly care less what someone says about me on some forum; except when they mis-represent me, which is what you're doing.

I say again: enjoy yourself, but stop assuming you know the first thing about how I'm reacting.
Yet, here you are reacting, thanks for proving my point over and over and over.:thumbsup::roflmao::roflmao: Let it go, you are missing my humor. Honestly though, I do wish you well, and have a great day!
 
I've recently started working with a drummer that "brought me in" to his group of two guitarists.
At the second jam, I was talking instruments with one of the guitarists, who has an affinity for 70s Asian knockoffs (lawsuit guitars, etc.). That's cool - I'm not a gear snob. When I started talking modestly about my collection (which he already hinted at having an American bias), this guy comes out with "Well, you know people who buy expensive instruments are compensating for their lack of ability", with a smirk on his face.
I was so amazed by his statement that I encouraged him to repeat it again... and he did! I played it off like it didn't bother me but it seemed RIDICULOUSLY passive-aggressive, and honestly, the drummer and I are playing at a higher level.
I mentioned a few reasons why I agree and disagree with what he said, but it still came across as a personal attack in the end.
I'm not worried about losing the drummer because he said he's been looking for a bassist like me for years.
I guess I'm kinda venting, but I'm on the fence with this guitarist now after his barbed statements. Very odd.
Have you run into anything similar?

"Well, you know people who buy expensive instruments are compensating for their lack of ability"

"Aha, so you must be a virtuoso". Pause. Laugh.

The guy's an idiot, don't sweat it. There are loads of socially awkward musicians.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marko 1
"Suuure, that's why the professionals all play Teiscos and Squires"
<extra points for substituting in the brand of guitar he's holding at that moment>

His statement is one of those situations where "It's not the instance, it's the pattern". (Jerry Jeff Walker said that about him being thrown into the NOLA drunk tank at a young age, but it's true about a lot of things.)
 
Last edited: