Hi everyone,
I've been using an FR800 for a few years now. It's been really great. Definitely the best cab that I've owned. One thing that I'm noticing as the gigs go by is that I don't really need a tweeter. I use a Demeter VTBP201S as my preamp, and often times I've got the treble knob down pretty low (I know that this preamp is a bit bright in general). I also have taken to using an OmniCabSim to make my distortion and fuzz sound nice with the cab, and I notice that I'm quite happy with the high response knob set pretty far down. It still sounds bright enough for my tastes. I also notice that I like the cab sim tone quite a bit when playing clean compared to the flat sound of the cab.
I'm thinking to switch to a Four 10 or possibly a Super Twin. The Four 10 seems more appealing because I think I might actually be happier with a more traditional baked in tone. I'm a little nervous that the sound will be too dark or inarticulate or something. I definitely want clean articulation and a nice midrange more than anything. I just wanted to get some opinions. I'd have to sell one before I could purchase the other!
I have a Big Twin and a Four10, both for bass only. They are both great. I’m not totally happy with either one.
The BT is pretty much FRFR, so it faithfully puts out what you put in, no added magic or excitement. Sometimes that works, but sometimes it doesn’t cut through a live mix as well as I would like, so I end up playing louder than I should to hear my pitches. Of course it can be eq’d, but FRFR with eq (even a nice one like an OCS) is not as satisfying as a good cabinet with some personality. YMMV.
The Four10 has a great low mid bump, in general I love the sound in the mix. It is super articulate in that I can hear the pitch and nuance of every note I play. But, it is quite dark. This is less of a problem when it’s cranked up loud, but it just doesn’t have as much as I’d like in the high mids and highs (especially in my hard rock/metal band). I know the specs say it goes up to 6k, but it doesn’t sound like it with a flat input signal. I can boost the high frequencies a LOT and then they are more audible, but it sounds a bit artifical then, and also my DI signal is crazy ice pick sounding at that point. It would be great if it had a good cone tweeter, but it doesn’t.
As I said earlier, this is my subjective taste, and these cabinets are both amazing in their own way.
But... In the next week or two I am going to be checking out Bergantino HDN and Mesa Subway cabinets to see if their compromises are more in line with what I hear in my head.