• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

One liners ?

What is the greatest bassline played on one string only ?

Here's is why I ask : I am messing around with fingerstyles and it's not going that great.
Having workershands, thick and stiff fingers I found playing a two-finger style over all 4 strings out of reach ... except the big E, simply because there is more space ...
In my depression I wondered maybe there is a great piece of music that requiers only one string of bass ... so ...
 
What is the greatest bassline played on one string only ?

Here's is why I ask : I am messing around with fingerstyles and it's not going that great.
Having workershands, thick and stiff fingers I found playing a two-finger style over all 4 strings out of reach ... except the big E, simply because there is more space ...
In my depression I wondered maybe there is a great piece of music that requiers only one string of bass ... so ...

I don't know about one, but here's one of the best bass lines of all time played on 2 strings.
 
What style of music do you play?

Speed and accuracy are going to be paramount with the position shifts required.

With that said, two songs that can be played on one string immediately come to mind. These are fairly easy ones to get you started . . .

Tom Petty's Breakdown and Soft Cell's Tainted Love.
 
There are tons of songs that CAN be played on one string. If you want something to work on, work on figuring out how to shift strings so you don't have to play on one string.

Lots of bass players don't have "perfect" hands. Maybe a teacher could get you started in the right direction.

True. Every song that doesn't require more than one note at a time can, in theory, be played on one string.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Renaissance
Thanks for the replies !

Maybe my beloved bass is to 'smal' for me, which means the strings are to tight together (about 15mm), and
when I try to play lets say A i cannot get my finger depp enought to get a 'good grip' without touching the string beneath ... another effect is that E sounds much lounder when I play fingers than the other strings ... so I fall back to playing with plektrum but somehow that feels like cheeting ... shouldn't but does...

A teacher would be great, but I just cant pay those guys ...

I realise I'm not gonna be the greates bassist ev'r ... but I'm enjoying 'playing' and when I hit a not that sounds
nice and clean I'm happy and it relaxes me even a bit ...

I didn't know there was basses with two strings, that actually could work for me ... but its gonna be hard to find one in the forests of Sweden and even harder to pay for it ...
Ironicly or maybe stupiditly I wish for a 5-string because sometines I play I miss some deeper notes to make it fit my ears ... Thanks to being a metalworker I now can't hear frequencys over 2000Hz no more ... but deep tones I hear very well ... And when my stupid hearing-aid isn't out off battery again I can hear it all ...

I try to play to 'Breakdown' and 'Tainted love', I just listned to them shortly but I like them ...

I don't know much about style, I think I may can tell Rock from Pop and Jazz from Hiphop , but where goes Hardrock into Metall or Rave into Techno and House ? In my years I'v listened to a lot of music from all genres but only lately I find myself listening into the music of songs ... not really deep but I realized there is so much more to hear if I try to focus on the bassline or so ... thats actually kinde hard to do, staying focused ...

I thougt of uploading some of my bass examples, but I havent figured out the 'cableworks' yet ...
 
Thanks for the replies !

Maybe my beloved bass is to 'smal' for me, which means the strings are to tight together (about 15mm), and
when I try to play lets say A i cannot get my finger depp enought to get a 'good grip' without touching the string beneath ... another effect is that E sounds much lounder when I play fingers than the other strings ... so I fall back to playing with plektrum but somehow that feels like cheeting ... shouldn't but does...

A teacher would be great, but I just cant pay those guys ...

I realise I'm not gonna be the greates bassist ev'r ... but I'm enjoying 'playing' and when I hit a not that sounds
nice and clean I'm happy and it relaxes me even a bit ...

I didn't know there was basses with two strings, that actually could work for me ... but its gonna be hard to find one in the forests of Sweden and even harder to pay for it ...
Ironicly or maybe stupiditly I wish for a 5-string because sometines I play I miss some deeper notes to make it fit my ears ... Thanks to being a metalworker I now can't hear frequencys over 2000Hz no more ... but deep tones I hear very well ... And when my stupid hearing-aid isn't out off battery again I can hear it all ...

I try to play to 'Breakdown' and 'Tainted love', I just listned to them shortly but I like them ...

I don't know much about style, I think I may can tell Rock from Pop and Jazz from Hiphop , but where goes Hardrock into Metall or Rave into Techno and House ? In my years I'v listened to a lot of music from all genres but only lately I find myself listening into the music of songs ... not really deep but I realized there is so much more to hear if I try to focus on the bassline or so ... thats actually kinde hard to do, staying focused ...

I thougt of uploading some of my bass examples, but I havent figured out the 'cableworks' yet ...


Is there an injury or maybe something like Arthritis that is limiting your movement in your hand? You said you were a metal worker, do you find it easier to play with your fingers on your off days from work? Have you improved even a little bit since you started playing with your fingers? I bet you have.

I would suggest whenever you sit down to practice. Warm up for a few minutes with scales using a pick. Then play those same scales at a slow tempo with your fingers. If you need to go even simpler than that then just focus on trying to pluck open strings with the best finger attack you can. After 10 or 15 minutes of that move on to playing songs you like with a pick. There's absolutely nothing wrong with playing with a pick so have a bit of fun after the work with the fingers. We all learn things at different rates so don't get to discouraged just put some work in at it consistently and you will improve over time.


If you prefer those lower frequencies you can try tuning your bass so it is BEAD instead of EADG. It's possible that due to your bass and strings that B may be a bit floppy but it's quick and free to try it.
 
Thanks for all the replies !

I really hope I dont have an injury in my hands, i have to use them for 40more years ... I'm not the guy who's getting a serious retirement on day ... Sweden is really nice but expensive !
Once I had kind a flow when I played with three finges on big E, I was just messing around, and it wasn't that good quality in the sound but my fingers moved so fluently, light and right timed, like a little rapid finger ballet,
that was really nice to watch ... they almost went automaticly ... if I just remembered how I did it :-o

I will try tuning to BEAD, i guess it might not work because the E alrady feels kinda floppy ... I have a Hohner B2 headless, probalbly not the best bass to have ... but when I put on new strings and got rid off all the effects from the Behringer Vamp, I really enjoyed its pure sound ...

The big E is sort off louder on my bass, its kinda differ from the others. I'm toying with the idea to lower the mics under ... but that even lowers the mic under A a bit so that probably wont work ...

Peter Gunn / Blues Brothers ! Of course, what a great line to worm upp !
 
Maybe my beloved bass is to 'smal' for me, which means the strings are to tight together (about 15mm), and
when I try to play lets say A i cannot get my finger depp enought to get a 'good grip' without touching the string beneath ... another effect is that E sounds much lounder when I play fingers than the other strings ... so I fall back to playing with plektrum but somehow that feels like cheeting ... shouldn't but does...
It might well be that you need a bass with wider string spacing, but it might also be a problem with your plucking technique. You don't need (or even want) to "get your finger deep enough to get a 'good grip'." You really only need to brush your "plucking" finger across the top of the string and then let it come to rest on the next string; you don't want to push the string downward (toward the bass boy). Try turning up the amp high enough that it's too loud when you "dig in," and work on "plucking" as softly as you can. (I keep putting the word "plucking" in quotes because it's really not the right word to describe what you're doing; in fact, "plucking" is almost the exact opposite of what you want to do.)
 
It might well be that you need a bass with wider string spacing, but it might also be a problem with your plucking technique. You don't need (or even want) to "get your finger deep enough to get a 'good grip'." You really only need to brush your "plucking" finger across the top of the string and then let it come to rest on the next string; you don't want to push the string downward (toward the bass boy). Try turning up the amp high enough that it's too loud when you "dig in," and work on "plucking" as softly as you can. (I keep putting the word "plucking" in quotes because it's really not the right word to describe what you're doing; in fact, "plucking" is almost the exact opposite of what you want to do.)

Interesting ! I usualy turn down the Gain to avoid the red light DB's on the EQ, and because my speakers (ordinary stereo) kinde shut down on low'nloud frequencies ...
It's totaly possible I'm doing it all wrong ... I once tried akustic and E-guitar and that didn't work out ... I think I have the 'rip the string' in my finges from playing akustic.
And when I get you right I 'just' have to increase bassamp-volume and 'lick' the top of the string gently ?
I don't realy know what 'lick' means but I heard it mentioned together with bass ...
 
Well, first, you really need to get yourself a real bass amp/speaker. The purpose of an electric bass is to produce "low and loud"you' sounds, so if you're using speakers that can't do that, you're missing the whole point! Even a small, inexpensive combo amp will be much much better than your stereo speakers -- and you're much less likely to accidentally damage it by playing too loud and low. Also, it is difficult to properly practice your technique if you can't hear yourself well enough, as you can't really tell if what you're doing sounds the way it is supposed to. Until then, do you have some decent headphones? If so, use those instead of your speakers.

Second, if you really want to learn how to do this, I recommend that you do exactly the opposite of what you're trying to do now: You should practice entirely on the A, D, and G strings, and avoid the E string completely, until you get your plucking technique right. It appears that the technique you are using to pluck the E string doesn't work on the other strings, so you need to learn how to pluck those other strings. Then you can work on plucking the E string in the same way.

Third, yes: you only have to "lick" the top of the string. That's a pretty good word, actually -- though not in the meaning that's usually associated with bass or guitar (i.e., "to play a lick"). In English, to "lick" something is to use your tongue to, for example, taste it, as you might do with an ice-cream cone, or the way a cat or dog might lick your hand or face. You don't need to push the string down, or even really pull on it; you just need to make enough contact with it to make a sound. If you do this gently it won't make a loud sound, but that's what your amp is for.

Does all that make sense?