• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Open strings not "clanking" when slapped

Hi folks,
I have a problem with my Warwick Corvette $$ 5 strings...When slapping, it sounds to me like the open B - E - A strings don't make the usual "clank" you would expect/look for when using such playing style, expecially the E string...the fretted notes sounds better, but the open string ones are to my ears somewhat...muffled, for lack of a better word.
I set up the bass following Warwick's tutorials on YouTube, for the B string the action is 2mm at 12th fret and 2,25 at 24th, for the E string it's 1,75 at 12th and 1,50 at 24th.

The strings are D'Addario Prosteels tapered 43 - 127

I attach a short audio clip where I play the open string followed by the first fretted note (so it's B/C, E/F, A/A#)...As I said, it sounds to me like the open strings cannot hit the frets properly, expecially the E, to the point that it's more clanky when I play fingerstyle hitting harder than slapping...

The strings are not new, I don't recall exactly when I put them on but they're not years old, the setting should be ok to achieve a decent slap sound (altough I'm not that good at slapping, never used it very much..). What could it be? Maybe it's the "natural", intrinsic Corvette slap sound? Or is it my technique that sucks so much I cannot even hit the strings properly (although I don't have the same sound problem with my Spector, the "clank" is always there even when the strings are a bit old...)?
 

Attachments

This could be a Tedur (plastic) vs brass nut. If it's only open strings it's most likely the nut.
I was reading about this topic and how the brass Just-a-Nut has a better resonance when it comses to open strings...I also considered replacing the tedur nut, but the brass one would cost 77 euros (!!), plus I don't know if I would risk doing the job myselfand that would add a supplementary cost...
Do you think new strings/lighter gauge (say, 40-120 or so) could have any effect?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Reedt2000
I was reading about this topic and how the brass Just-a-Nut has a better resonance when it comses to open strings...I also considered replacing the tedur nut, but the brass one would cost 77 euros (!!), plus I don't know if I would risk doing the job myselfand that would add a supplementary cost...
Do you think new strings/lighter gauge (say, 40-120 or so) could have any effect?
Honestly I don't think strings will help much. If it's only open, the nut is more than likely the culprit. This has been discussed quite a bit in the Warwick club here on TB, and everyone says the brass upgrade is worth it. Your Spector has a brass nut....