• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

p pickup help : /

ive got a bc rich bich witha single p in it and i hated the sound of the stock pickup so i just replaced it with a bart i had thinking ide get a clearer tone. unfortunatly the bart didnt have the grunt with crystal highs i was hoping for. im looking for a pup that will sound clear with distortion and be clear when power chords are played. anybody have any sugestions? i was kinda thinking to try a quarter pounder but ive never used duncans so i dont know if it would be too much in the mids. also i use the lowest 4 strings from a 5 string set on it so i can tune it to b or c.
 
how close is the pickup height to the strings?
what kind of strings are you using?
what kind of amp?
what did you not like about the stock pickup?

these are just a few of the questions i would consider answering. they all can play a factor.
 
Those stock NJ pickups were Gotoh, basically a MIJ DiMarzio knockoff. They have problems with microphonics and they're just not as good as the real thing. I always change them.

The Duncan QP is a great pickup, but alnico doesn't have the high end of a ceramic pup.

Go with a real DiMarzio. If you want more highs get the Model P. If you want more beef and grunt get the Will Power Middle. The Split P might have the "crystal highs" you're looking for - but it will be overly scooped sounding, so not a good candidate for distortion.


ive got a bc rich bich witha single p in it and i hated the sound of the stock pickup so i just replaced it with a bart i had thinking ide get a clearer tone. unfortunatly the bart didnt have the grunt with crystal highs i was hoping for. im looking for a pup that will sound clear with distortion and be clear when power chords are played. anybody have any sugestions? i was kinda thinking to try a quarter pounder but ive never used duncans so i dont know if it would be too much in the mids. also i use the lowest 4 strings from a 5 string set on it so i can tune it to b or c.
 
Dimarzio model P with the adjustable pole peices raised just a little above the pup housing. Little more so on the E&A or B&E strings. pair it with nice 2band preamp stacked bass/treble pot like the Basslines blackout and youd have a very nice P pup bass imo. Not quite as crunchy a sound as the dimarzio P as the BC Rich P's their best version have covered top (no exposed pole peices like the cheaper models have), but still the dimarzio model P has decent crunch factor. Which aids articulation imo.
 
yeah the stock pup is muddy weak and dosent have any definition. sounds like a dimarzio p or split p is what im looking for i like scooped mids and crunch as im playing old school death metal. im trying to go for a classic shane embury distortion with a scooped mids crisp crunch if possible.
 
scooped + distortion doesn't work. you can try it, but the distortion sounds like crap. examples - MXR M-80 where you can't disable the color (scoop) switch on the distortion channel. or any EMG with distortion.

distortion eats mids. for good tone you gotta feed it.

shane embury distortion? an original RAT will get you damn close.