• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Picked the wrong bass or my hands need more training?

I can stretch my pinky when playing from the first fret to the fourth fret. Having said that, it's not comfortable doing it on very many songs and it seems unnatural to me. Practice will improve your reach, but unless you have young hands it will be uncomfortable for very long.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EatS1stBassist
Rocco Prestia didn’t stretch. He just moved his hand up and down the fretboard, and he played some pretty busy bass lines.

Sometimes top achievers have unconventional methods.

Try to find and develop a style that works for you. Just don’t disregard advice or instruction that may help you avoid discomfort or injury.
Rocco is great—- one of my all time favorites.
That said, not all “busy” bass lines are difficult.
Difficulty comes in when there are crazy interval jumps—- that’s where well written exercises in method books put the best players to the test.
Or get a trombone or cello book that require some melodic phrasing.
 
I'm 5'11" and got to move my hand a bit when my index is on the 1st fret and I want to play a note on the 4th fret with my pinky. The scale length of my bass is 34"

I know a popular bassist named Tetsuya Ogawa from japanese group l'Arc-en-ciel who's 5'6" and the scale length of his bass is 35"...

This makes me wonder if I should go for a small/medium scale bass OR if I just need more "stretch training" lol
Keep the bass, forget about stretching and learn to shift. :thumbsup:
 
  • Like
Reactions: EatS1stBassist
Keep the bass, forget about stretching and learn to shift. :thumbsup:
I do love my bass A LOT and this suggestion wouldn't involve getting the medium scale pink SX pj bass OR the month of training lol. For a moment I felt like trying the month of training and see if it works but I haven't considered stretching in the long run. If things aren't the same with old hands perhaps I should get used to shifting right away
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: EatS1stBassist
Rocco Prestia didn’t stretch. He just moved his hand up and down the fretboard, and he played some pretty busy bass lines.

Sometimes top achievers have unconventional methods.

Try to find and develop a style that works for you. Just don’t disregard advice or instruction that may help you avoid discomfort or injury.
What he said
 
I do love my bass A LOT and this suggestion wouldn't involved getting the medium scale pink SX pj bass OR the month of training lol. For a moment I felt like trying the month of training and see if it works but I haven't considered stretching in the long run. If things aren't the same with old hands perhaps I should get used to shifting right away
Absolutely
 
I do love my bass A LOT and this suggestion wouldn't involved getting the medium scale pink SX pj bass OR the month of training lol. For a moment I felt like trying the month of training and see if it works but I haven't considered stretching in the long run. If things aren't the same with old hands perhaps I should get used to shifting right away
I think you would love that pink SX
 
I think you would love that pink SX
But I must admit it is a pretty bass can't deny it lol!

Now that I'm home and that I'm messing with my bass I notice that before I shift my thumb is perpendicular holding the middle of the back of the neck between my 2nd and 3rd finger and when I shift to reach the 4th fret my thumb is angled at 45 degrees

Should your thumb always be perpendicular or it's normal that it forms an angle when shifting?
 
Last edited:
But I must admit it is a pretty bass can't deny it lol!

Now that I'm home and that I'm messing with my bass I notice that before I shift my thumb is perpendicular holding the middle of the back of the neck between my 2nd and 3rd finger and when I shift to reach the 4th fret my thumb is angled at 45 degrees

Should your thumb always be perpendicular or it's normal that it forms an angle when shifting?
Some people keep their thumb perpendicular some don’t. My hands are small. But I never let that stop me from playing my P bass. Shifting on a scale size 34+ is mandatory. You don’t want to see pics of my fingers. Lol. I have to compensate like mad. At 67 It’s very painful for me to play. Recently I switched to Rotosound FunkMasters. Very light. It felt like a warm bath. Ah...
I was able to play lines that for years I was unable to play. Above all make yourself comfortable. Billy Gibbons uses 7 gauge on his guitars. There is no loss of tone! Just Resistance.
 
But I must admit it is a pretty bass can't deny it lol!

Now that I'm home and that I'm messing with my bass I notice that before I shift my thumb is perpendicular holding the middle of the back of the neck between my 2nd and 3rd finger and when I shift to reach the 4th fret my thumb is angled at 45 degrees

Should your thumb always be perpendicular or it's normal that it forms an angle when shifting?
And yes I’m thinking about pulling the trigger on that and modding the heck out of it.
 
Some people keep their thumb perpendicular some don’t. My hands are small. But I never let that stop me from playing my P bass.

Above all make yourself comfortable
What a relief and amen to that: "make yourself comfortable"
And yes I’m thinking about pulling the trigger on that and modding the heck out of it.
They make killer custom basses when you pick an SX as your base for a good price!
 
  • Like
Reactions: EatS1stBassist
SX basses can be sweet. I've got two of them, myself! :)

If you are curious what 32" feels like, get a hold of a guitar capo and put it at the 1st fret of your 34" bass. If you want to experience what 30" feels like, move the capo to the 2nd fret. It won't give you the exact sensation, but it is a cheap and easy "try before you buy." :)