• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Practice Amps: Ampeg VS Fender

The Hartke HD25 is really great for 129 bucks. Just bought one and quite impressed at it's sound and build quality. I can turn the bass knob up to 3:00 and the volume at 3:00 and it doesn't distort at all. Gets a good proggy sound the with bass and treble at 3:00 and the mid at 9:00 (scooped). The hybrid speaker has some zing.
 
I just whipped over to G.C.'s site:

Acoustic 50.
1-10" driver.
50 watts.
Tilt back cabinet.
$199.99.

(And if you could go just a little more $ for a much more capable amp.)

Acoustic 100.
1-12" driver.
100 watts.
Tilt back cabinet.
$279.00.
I have the 12, it sounds great with every bass and I practice through it all the time
FDAAD7A8-7C5A-4323-B8E0-7B11E412F01B.jpeg
 
I’m considering picking up the smallest and cheapest possible practice amp for acoustic jam sessions and just overall ease and portability. It’d be nice if it sounded OK, too.

I’m looking at the Fender Rumble 15 and the Ampeg BA-108 on the Long & McQuade website. Both are 15W 1x8 combos, and both around $150 CAD.

The price is right. I don’t really want to go up over $200 for the next size up.

For additional consideration, A buddy has a larger Fender Rumble combo and I have never gotten a sound out of it that I like.

Thoughts??
The Fender but personally, peavey max100 is probably the greatest puny combo amp ever made.
 
i like and recommend the rumble 25 but disliked the 15 - it had no bass. if you love ampeg, the ampeg is worth getting, but mine a few years didn't come with the kickback.

cheap with lots of bass, i'd also suggest the hartke HD15. or is that HD-15? its tiny speaker defies physics :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: NKBassman
I had a situation recently, where I forgot to bring my mini head along with my cab to an outdoor band practice. There was a Rumble 25 available, so I used it grudgingly. It sounded amazing (!) up against two 40-watt tube guitar amps and a full drum set. I only had it 3/4 cranked too. The band said it did the job very well. I plan on using it again at our next outdoor practice this weekend.

Anyway, try each amp before you buy. Use your ears more than your eyes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NKBassman
I've gotten a bunch of different used amps for under $100-US: a couple of different first gen Rumbles, one with a 12 and one with a 15 and I only spent $125 for an Ampeg BA112 in pristine condition. I've also bought a Hartke KB-1200 and an SWR LAB-12 for $100 each, but swapped them away pretty quick, along with a first-gen Ampeg BA-115 that worked well, but was in rough shape -- also $100. (I liked the sound of that one well enough, but hated the form factor for a small amp.) My point is that buying used can be advantageous -- even the one's I didn't keep were better amps for your purpose than either of your new choices, IMO. Of those two, I'd prefer the Ampeg.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NKBassman
I had the v1 Ampeg 108, it was killer. I even cranked it to 3:00 and pitted it against a drumset once! (A little strained, but it did ok) for acoustic jams, it was always plenty.

I have the Rumble 25 now. I like it a whole lot. I think the key with the rumbles is dropping the bass knob to 10:00 or so. I think they’re made to be extra bassy to sound impressive in the store...
Absolutely accurate regarding the Rumble bass knob. They have some great sounds on tap, but you’ve got to get your head around cutting the low end.
 
Looks like the Rumble 25 is only $169 CAD. I must have been looking at the 40 yesterday.

Hartke HD15 and HD25 are also available. The HD25 is $199 which is pushing the limit.

Sounds like I need to get myself down to the store and plug a few of these in. Ampeg is a little more my vibe but the Rumble 25 is on the list now.
 
Last edited:
Absolutely accurate regarding the Rumble bass knob. They have some great sounds on tap, but you’ve got to get your head around cutting the low end.
A Rumble 100 was my only gig amp for a while, it’s still my rehearsal amp. I discovered setting the 4-band to 10/2/2/10, it’s like I got a whole new amp. My 25 is just for home use, so I’m cool with the flat “bedroom tone” from that amp. Playing with the OD too, I feel like I get some Ampeggy tone from it. (25 just has an OD button, not variable.)

Now I have a Markbass for my gig rig (sweet spot in terms of clarity for me.) I’ve been back-lined GK and Genz Benz (a little too clean for my taste.)

This all may be TMI for the OP, especially since he’s leaning Ampeg or Traynor now. But my point is- in the grand scheme of things, I find the Rumbles and BAs to be more similar than different. And at low volumes, it’s an even bigger non-issue. All IMHO, of course.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NKBassman
The Rumble 25 is Fender's answer to the Ampeg BA-108 and both are very good amps. The Rumble 15 is cheaper and not much of an amp.
Of the two, I would go with an Ampeg BA-108 over the Rumble 25. If you go up to a 10" speaker, I'd pick the Rumble 40 over the BA-110, if for nothing else than the fact that it weighs half of what the Ampeg does.