John Kallas 57 Precision with 64 jazz profile neck.
![]()
That is gorgeous.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
John Kallas 57 Precision with 64 jazz profile neck.
![]()
I read that a Fender neck pocket is the same for both jazz and P bass necks, but I am not so sure. If someone could confirm this, I would love to know. Otherwise, the other options are availabe. I believe a Jag has a jazz width nut and has a P pickup. And a J bridge pickup if you want it.
Sorry .. my short judgement about neck profile and hand cramps is ... BSAFAIK, this mod was one of the first popular with bass players back in the 70's. A lot of guys were putting J necks on the P. Also, Fender made P's in the '71 - '72 time-frame which had Jazz Bass profiled necks. I know because my first Fender I bought in 1972 was a P with the thinner neck. Wish I still had it. For all of CBS' mess-ups, this was one mod which made some sense. So, yes, they are somewhere out there.
All that said, with a lot more years of playing, my 2c is that the neck profile actually influences tone more than anything, and that neither profile is "faster" or easier on the hands than the other. The thinner neck is more flexible and that has direct influence on the resonant characteristics of the instrument, with neither being either better or worse, just different, IMO.
If you are actually having hand cramps playing a P neck, you might want to get some lessons, cause that should not be happening using any kind of decent left hand technique. And not to say that you might prefer the J anyhow.
No, I didn't imply anything like that. Just trying to offer that some alternate fingering techniques might help.Sorry .. my short judgement about neck profile and hand cramps is ... BS
Bucephylus old or not you stated that difficulties in playing a bass do not depend, never, on the shape of the instrument's neck ... I absolutely don't agree with this statement.No, I didn't imply anything like that. Just trying to offer that some alternate fingering techniques might help.
Did you actually read my 5 year old post, or am I not understanding yours?
Fully agree with you ..: the A necks are very comfortable ... I can play the wider ones but not with the same fluidity as the as the A neck ... when I bought my PB70 honestly I was looking at the TV logo on the headstock thinking about the possibility to install the Fender stamped 70s tuners behind as the holes pattern was thd right one..I have a '72/73 P with an "A" neck. Love it. For years I didn't realize it was not a normal P neck, until I bought a '62 AVRI P. I hated the neck. Couldn't figure out was wrong until I measured them... sold the AVRI, and bought a Jazz. In love with both now...
For this post and that of Bucephylus ... I also have small hands ... I took lessons from a guy who played both electric and upright basses ... He taught how to use the left hand with the thumb positioned on the centre of the neck and that's the way I play ... personally I laugh a bit when I see guitar players with the thumb on the fretboard ... I can play thicker and wider necks but I have stiffness in my back and neck a this causes fatguing ... therefore I prefer thinner necks and I can easily find differences in the way a neck can affect my playing ... Bucephylus I'm not Marcus Miller but I believe I have a good technique and this should not be an issue preventing me from appreciating wider necks ... that is that not all people are the same ...I have really small hands and I spent a large amount of my playing time on upright so I can tell you that if you learn to play with the print of your thumb in the center of the back of the neck you will be comfortable with wider necks. I personally don't like anything narrower than 1 5/8" at the nut and I am most comfortable with wider necks.
+1. No universal truths; and players most definitely need to use the tool that fits them best.Fully agree with you ..: the A necks are very comfortable ... I can play the wider ones but not with the same fluidity as the as the A neck ... when I bought my PB70 honestly I was looking at the TV logo on the headstock thinking about the possibility to install the Fender stamped 70s tuners behind as the holes pattern was thd right one..
The price was very low (I bought it from Ishibashi) and it seemed in good conditions so I bought without playing it and without knowing the history of the Fender P bass necks.
I was very lucky ! Bass was ok, finish was very good and I had immediately good feelings about the neck which was only a couple of mm wider and thicker than my other jazz basses... so I made some researches and I learned about the A necks...
That's why I wanted to buy a Nate Mendel ..
Thanks Buc! Nice words indeed, you're a good TBer guy !+1. No universal truths; and players most definitely need to use the tool that fits them best.
That said, there are players with absurdly small hands who play full scale uprights with facility that would make your hair stand on end. My only point, which I still stand by, is that there are techniques out there which can address problems we all face.
From yet a third perspective, Billie Holiday had less than an octave of useful vocal range, and look what she did with it. So, there's also that.
As to being Marcus Miller; well, none of us are. You need to just be yourself, and be the best at that you can be. Don't let anyone tell you any different.![]()
Thanks. Just trying to give what I get around here.Thanks Buc! Nice words indeed, you're a good TBer guy !![]()