• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

punk eq?

Having actually been known as a "punk artist" for the past 30 years, and having done many shows at CBGB's, everywhere in Boston and a ton of rat holes in between, I will first correct one poster here. Punk was NOT about anti-establishment. It WAS about DIY, the alternative to the then dominant, over-produced, arena album rock at the time. Think ELO, then strip all the Jeff Lynne out of it. Boston, without the million thick guitars and perfectly done vox. Think three minute songs, not three hour songs.

Second, best advice I ever got was from a punk legend. When it came to bass, your bass itself should be turned all the way up, including the tone. Every pickup should be in (although lets face it, most of us had some variation of a P-Bass or a Ric then because cheap P's and Rics could be found) Since in the beginning we didn't have amps with graphic eq, and sometimes we used guitar amps, the bass, treble and mid (if you had it) would all be relatively equal, although you would normally put the bass and treble one notch higher then the mid.

String choice doesn't really matter either. Great tones from Graham Maby (tapewounds), Paul Simonen (rounds) and Bruce Foxton (I seem to remember he had both flats and rounds on his rics, just depended on the color he was using that day.)

Punk was never meant to be a musical style. It was a movement. And not a social movement, but a musical movement. Much of what was labeled punk then was also pop. "Should I Stay or Should I Go." Is it a pop record or a punk record? See...
Even all these years later, you're points are still valid! Actually, your WHOLE DISSEMINATION is correct.

Punk; DIY- to the max.

Play what you feel- to the max.

Play it loud with gear that might fail at any moment- to the max!

Punk is just as relevant today as it was in 1977. to parallel your comment on on ELO and Boston- sub in Beyonce and Katy Perry! LOL. See? Still relevant!

Thank you for calling things as they truly are!
 
  • Like
Reactions: murphy
Classic punk bass tones: pick playing and amps pushed into grit. So, think midrange.

Here's that feel from a couple bands that borrowed bits of punk—especially in their bass parts:

The Clash, "London Calling"

Uncle Tupelo, "Factory Belt"

The Poster Children, "Dynamite Chair"

Naked Raygun, "I Don't Know"
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: BadExample
Classic punk bass tones: pick playing and amps pushed into grit. So, think midrange.

Here's that feel from a couple bands that borrowed bits of punk—especially in their bass parts:

The Clash, "London Calling"

Uncle Tupelo, "Factory Belt"

The Poster Children, "Dynamite Chair"

Naked Raygun, "I Don't Know"



One could do worse than the clash bass tone, especially from the early years when they had a more punkish tone.

 
  • Like
Reactions: dune2k and Wisebass
Wow! A 8 year old thread about Punk EQ resurrected! :hyper::hyper::hyper:

punksnotdead - Copie.jpg


Classic punk bass tones: pick playing and amps pushed into grit. So, think midrange.

one more for the list :bassist:



Wise(b)ass
 
I doubt if you asked any punk bassist what tonewoods were best for his style, which fingerboard material he preffered and whether or not he thinks poly is better than nitro, he is going to look at you cross eyed!

Originals punk player here, I'm not going to look at you cross-eyed. I am going to tell you:
1) You're a little old to believe in the Tonewood Fairy
2) Straight(ish) and level(ish), see Tonewood Fairy
3) I'm not familiar with the local microbrews... but I'll try 'em both.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EastCoastThump
When I think punk tone, I think it is usually a lean gritty "all in the mids" kind of tone. On a four-band eq, I would cut the bass and the treble to boost the mids. I would pluck or pick closer to the bridge and when you pluck/pick; do it hard. You want the strings to clank on the frets.
 
I tended to anchor my hand at the bridge and dig in with a pick. Though in my later period I tried experimenting with this weird thing called "dynamic". Other than that, get to a sweet spot on gain and cut high miss.
 
As a counterpoint to my own post, I doubt if you asked any punk bassist what tonewoods were best for his style, which fingerboard material he preffered and whether or not he thinks poly is better than nitro, he is going to look at you cross eyed!

First, preferred, not preffered. I prefer Ash mostly as a tonewood for bass, but really all have their unique defining characteristics and can be cool in their own way.

I think for bass the only fingerboard material this punk doesn't like is ebony. I feel like ebony often develops dead spots which for bass is a killer.

Poly versus nitro has always been mostly a marketing tool. Paint application can be done properly with either material. The instruments ability to breath is BS. For sure there are some porosity differences, but does anyone think that a 1952 tell sounded bad in 53 before it had a chance to breathe? I would also add that poly is actually easier to apply in thin coats, despite large companies not figuring that out.

Signed,

A punk bassist not cross eyed, except being blind in my left eye I'm always a little wonky.