• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Rounds vs. Flats

"The sound I’m going for in a current project works better with rounds." So, just use rounds. You'll get used to them. It's good you're putting what's right for the music before your personal preference. I'd say nickel rounds might be up your alley more than ss - they can feel "softer", a bit less finger noise perhaps. I'm an old Labella flats guy mostly but my second fave strings are DR Nickel Lo Riders.
But if it's just more "clank" your missing and not so much the "zing" of rounds, I agree new Chromes might do the trick for you (I have never tried Ernie Ball Cobalt Flats but sounds like they'd be worth a try too).
 
OP, you didn’t say whether your project is covers or originals and whether you’re performing in public. It matters because if you are, the audience may have a perception of what the band should sound like that might affect your choice.

If that is not the case, my view is that the most important thing is to play what makes you want to play. Differences in tone between roundwound and flatwound strings are waaay more important to bass players than to people who listen. So make yourself happy.

A couple viewpoints on string choices:

Chromes are flats. They don’t sound like rounds to me, they sound like flats. They feel exactly like flats. They are a bit brighter than some others.

EB Cobalts are awesome strings, they are extremely bright flats that actually can create a passable roundwound tone. The rumors are true there. The problem with them is the construction - they leave tiny spaces between the winds, which helps create the tone everyone loves. They also create the friction stickiness people talk about here. It’s definitely a thing, enough of one to get them off of my bass after a couple gigs.

D’Addario Half-Rounds are unloved around here for some reason. But I’ve had a set on my six string for 8 or 10 years; they are a nice, bright flat that can sit in a mix like a round. They are also sticky, like Cobalts, because of the process they use to grind them down. I think it leaves microscopic burrs on the string surface. Unlike Cobalts, the effect goes away after 10-15 playing hours. John Patitucci uses these on his electrics. Don’t sleep on these.

Pressurewounds are fantastic strings. I love them. They are absolutely roundwounds in tone and feel, though. Just maybe 25% smoother to feel than other rounds. But they do not sound like flats, at all. They sound like slightly broken in nickel rounds. They also sound great dead. I use these on most of my basses.
 
Last edited:
I’m using Dogal Hellborg flats on one bass, and I just replaced the TI Jazz flats on another with Dogal Hellborg rounds. They’re the first rounds I’ve used in like 15 years. I was using tapes for awhile, but I was getting way too much ground noise from those.

I'm not familiar with the Dogals unfortunately. If you can describe the feel, tone & tension you are after, @michael_t can often be a huge help in assisting people finding the strings they are looking for, he is quite well versed in all things strings.... I'm sure he will drop in here at some point.

@logdrum , cool & helpful examples!
 
  • Like
Reactions: logdrum
I’m sure this is a topic that has been debated to death, but I just needed a place to express my feelings about the subject, so please bear with me.

I like to play flats. They sound and feel better under my fingers, which in turn make me play better. The sound I’m going for in a current project works better with rounds. I’ve been able to dial in an acceptable tone, but I shaging hate playing rounds.

My question is do I keep playing the proper sound with the rounds I despise, or do I say shag it and dial in the closest tone with the flats?

There is no pressure either way- my bandmates are cool as all get out.

Play what you like. At worst, your bass will sound like an electric bass once the bullets are flying. Get about 20 feet from your speakers, very few are going to be able to tell the difference.

With regard to flat wound string usage, I will suggest you will not get shot, become broke , nor will your bass blow up if you replace your stings once in a while/ Especially if your are trying to get a sound like rounds using flats or don’t like the ones you currently using.

Secondly, some flats are better than others for getting more of a round wound sound. I’ll let the experts on the board fill you in on that. Me? I’m a dedicated round wound user for the last almost 50 years and don’t want to send you on an endless search.
 
  • Like
Reactions: StayLow
I’m sure this is a topic that has been debated to death, but I just needed a place to express my feelings about the subject, so please bear with me.

I like to play flats. They sound and feel better under my fingers, which in turn make me play better. The sound I’m going for in a current project works better with rounds. I’ve been able to dial in an acceptable tone, but I shaging hate playing rounds.

My question is do I keep playing the proper sound with the rounds I despise, or do I say shag it and dial in the closest tone with the flats?

There is no pressure either way- my bandmates are cool as all get out.

Well, I am not going to read this entire thread. Since when is music about what some bass player likes or doesn't like to play because one of them "feels better under my fingers?" Who cares, get over yourself! If the music needs rounds, THEN YOU SHOULD BE PLAYING ROUNDS!!
 
I’m sure this is a topic that has been debated to death, but I just needed a place to express my feelings about the subject, so please bear with me.

I like to play flats. They sound and feel better under my fingers, which in turn make me play better. The sound I’m going for in a current project works better with rounds. I’ve been able to dial in an acceptable tone, but I shaging hate playing rounds.

My question is do I keep playing the proper sound with the rounds I despise, or do I say shag it and dial in the closest tone with the flats?

There is no pressure either way- my bandmates are cool as all get out.
 
Lots of great ideas! I use TI Jazz Rounds (...$$ but live-up to the hype), Dunlop SuperBrights (...will my inventory NEVER run out?!?), Cobalt Flats, and LaBella LTF's. Pass on the Dunlops but the other 3 are strong contenders IME. If bound & determined to stick with roundwounds, the Jazz Rounds feel great under the fingertips. The PressureWounds are a great alternative and more conservatively priced.

Riis
Yep! Jazz rounds are great, sound like a round but are SUPER soft on the fingers.
 
My personal favorites are Ken Smith Compressors strings. I like their feel and tone much more than the ground wounds from D’addario and the pressure wound GHS strings (Smiths are much smoother). No finger squeal, no excessive fret noise like typical rounds, but still articulate. I use them for Rock. I’ve tried chromes and cobalts, and while I agree they are brighter than other flats, they still sound like flats to my ear (big fundamental, not a lot of overtones). For me, the Smith Compressors are the best compromise between rounds and flats (and my favorite string)
 
  • Like
Reactions: MattZilla
I’m using Dogal Hellborg flats on one bass, and I just replaced the TI Jazz flats on another with Dogal Hellborg rounds. They’re the first rounds I’ve used in like 15 years. I was using tapes for awhile, but I was getting way too much ground noise from those.

If you already tried Dogals, you are way ahead than most of us. I'd like to try, but not enough demos to convince me.