That's what I meant, when saying avoid assistance for pronation. I was born with flat feet, but when I was around 25 I went barefoot for a year and a half. In UK weather, that's not easy, and a misspent youth collecting scrap metal in derelict buildings (because I just got the idea it was a cool way to spend some time alone after the punk scene degenerated into too many nasty drugs), and doing that barefoot too, was a challenge, and it did me a lot of good, it made me less likely to pronate, and nothing else ever worked better. Because I spent most of the time literally up on my toes, some people thought I was a martial artist (I'm not, don't know much about any of that). I wear socks indoors now, mostly, but I like the 1000-mile ones made for the armed forces, I get pretty much the advertised mileage, probably. And they're cheaper than moccasins.I won't get into what, but I switched to minimalist shoes for the most part. No arch. Little or no padding...I'm constantly walk around barefoot when I'm able.
...try an experiment to see if perhaps you need to go the other way, rather than thicker and more squishy. For a zillion years we didn't walk around on squish...
Agreed. Better to have a bit of extra width than extra thickness. After my year-and-a-half I made this concession because I took up running on rough ground and didn't want to take my chances with tetanus. I'd already pushed my luck long and hard enough. Now, I just keep my weight modest for my height, it spares me most of the pain. Spinal injury (from working on a building site) and arthritis cause me enough, no point in tempting fate..