• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Should Bass Hang Low Or High

Should Bass Hang Low Or High


  • Total voters
    473
the last option is 50% good and 50% wrong

Good: Doesn't Matter
Wrong: High Or Low Doesn't Affect Anything


it affects it all! but you have to wear it in the way you feel comfortable, even if it's just for the looks, also you have to be able to play the kind of music you are trying to play!


I go for "Mid" in this poll cuz I play many styles, and I think bass looks ridiculous being played with a pick when it's high up, and it's impossible to play some high patterns when it's all the way down, so mid is the best for me

just like this

Ikuoabslive.gif


a bit higher is fine too
 
Having dealt with some hand problems lately which lead me to several specialists in the field of musical performance injuries, I believe there IS an ideal position for the bass. Predictably, it's "not too low, not too high."

When I went in first they had me put my bass on and play some, and they immediately pointed out that I had it much too high. Playing the bass high improves fret accessibility, but it comes at the expense of healthy playing form. Your fretting hand elbow must bend at a sharper angle, which puts more stress and stretch on your ulnar nerve at your elbow which can manifest itself in many of the problems often thought to be rooted in the wrist (tingling and numbness in the fingers, hand pain). It also encourages awkward wrist angles in the plucking hand unless you bring that elbow far forward, which puts more strain on the shoulder.

Playing the bass too low leads to improper fretting hand technique in that it forces to angle your wrist at an extreme angle in order to fret notes. (I think the problems with this style are more obvious and known to most here so I won't go in to it).

Essentially, you want to play at the height that imposes the least angle on ALL joints involved in playing the bass. The elbows should be relaxed and open, wrists should be straight, and the fingers should be nicely arched. This has nothing to do with looking good or the genre you're trying to play, and everything to do with keeping your body as healthy as you can for as long as possible.
 
Man, aint none of y'all place it so the upper horn is in direct contact with your breastbone? No showman here, so I dont give a ratass what it looks like, you see. But I dig that's relevant in certain realms. Nonetheless, I like to feel the wood IN my body. From teh instrument, not the drivers behind me. Vibrations near my solar plexus. And if the bass fits me right, I reckon it'll natually place the instrument smack dead in TFUnkadelic's "minimum angle across all joints" positon, which, of course, is the correct logical and mathematical solution.
 
when people wear their bass really low it just makes them look like a tool.
Whatever. I bet you wouldn't say that to Trujillo's face. He used to play with those Suicidal Tendencies guys and knows about twenty different ways to cap yo' ass OG style.

I wear mine pretty low usually. Not near as low as Trujillo because I don't want WhiteKong to think I look like a tool (his approval is very important to me), but I don't feel comfortable when it's really high. If I have to play more difficult music, I'll wear it higher because it makes it a little easier, but how high do you need it to be able to play "Papa Ooo Mow Mow"? I can be a bit of a technique nazi while practicing, but not on a gig. It's all about the show on the gig.
 
watch that left thumb.

i've always been a thumb-over kinda player... at least when it feels comfortable and makes whatever i'm playing easier. is there a medical reason you've learned not to do this? i'd like to hear it. i don't want permanent injuries sooner nor later.

i think my positioning is pretty good. the basses i have now are quite heavy, so that puts some strain on my shoulder when i use a strap, but if i just remind myself to relax and listen to which muscles are getting tired, i seem to do ok. my bass is typically 'sitting height' when strapped.

i do really enjoy those stands that hold your instrument for you. i made something quite similar for my little martin backpacker classical guitar because the thing's so damned light and tiny i can't move my hand without the guitar following. keeps it at what i feel is the perfect angle [for what i play on that instrument], even though it looks a little silly.
 
as high as my leather strap allows.. which is a couple inches shorter than id like it.

i tend to swing my fingers down at the strings violently and hurt myself, so the higher my bass, the less i swing.

well.. i still swing baby :D

so my fretting hand doesnt really matter, and i never tried to look a certain way, but i keep it up there for technique. i get made fun of all the time.

had a guy pick up my bass once and try to put it on.. he could hardly get it over his head, and he laughed as he mocked how id play with it that high.. jokes on him.. because hes a tool and i TOTALLY stole that show MYSELF. HA. take that, metalhead assbag.
 
I used to know a guitarist that wore it so low that when I put his guitar on, it almost touched my knees. He was a really good player with good feel and tone. He looked "cool", I suppose. I couldn't even play a power chord in that position. My wrist was so angled that I couldn't imagine soloing in that position, even though he was pretty fast.

To each his own, but I prefer the bass high enough that it doesn't rest on my legs when I practice while sitting down. In fact, I always play with my strap on so that I'm used to that position whether standing or sitting. Someone once commented how I looked like a nerd with the bass so high up. I asked them how I sounded.