• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Small bass synth keyboard recommendations

Monologue and Minilogue are excellent analogs and I don't think you'll regret it. If you decide to keep looking then I'd throw in another mention for the Bass Station II and Microbrute. The GAIA MkI is useful for a full featured polysynth but twice the size and not nearly as specialised to bass mono sounds.

The PolyBoog is my personal favourite but you do have to accept some Minimoog design compromises compared to modern synths - heavy, basic routing and functionality, hard patching everything on the fly, no onboard tuning assistance. Sounds like a Mini for a tenth of the price once it's running and looks cool as hell though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rojo412
Seeing what I saw (and of course, only online because "in store" is a pipe dream anymore), the takeaways I was getting from everything mentioned so far:

- Gaia: as cool as it seems, it IS a large board. Would love it for home, but in my band setting, it would be cramped.
- Taktile: the 25 would be sweet, but 49 would be large. Oddly enough, I found a 49 for CHEAP, but again - cramped space.
- Minilogue: still awesome, but a significant amount more than the Monologue I found.
- Bass Station II: people were comparing this directly to the Monologue and they were close. It's at least $100 more though, so for the form factor and functions, it seems like the Monologue is the safer bet for the moment.

If this does take off for me and I find myself limited by the Monologue, I wouldn't hesitate to buy something fancier down the road. And it is nice to hear feedback on all of this (and I hope this thread helps someone else who is also contemplating similar moves, too). So yeah, thanks again for helping out, it's great info to gather.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rev_Slinky
An iPad or iPhone and a MIDI controller can do wonders. I have used the Garageband synths on many occasions to great effect.
that‘s what I am doing in one band I‘m playing with.
In the meantime with dedicated synth apps other than Garageband.
I enjoy the versatility, but the slight downside is the amount of cables going to and from the iPad and the MIDI Keyboard I‘m using.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rojo412
Yeah, I dig what GB can do on so many levels. And I do plan on using any of these for some of their capabilities for MIDI on my desktop.
But at band... I'd need too many cables and my fat hands wouldn't be deft enough to hit the proper note on my phone the same way as a larger actual keyboard.
 
I had an Arturia MiniBrute v1. Love the sounds and the features, including full amp and filter ADSR. All knobs and sliders are right in front of you - no menus. By the time I bought it, my core bass synth tones had already been set, so I wasn't using it enough, otherwise I'd still have it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rojo412
Again, so many thanks for all of the recommendations...

I did a calculated thing - I bought the MONOLOGUE from the local GC for a number of reasons:
1) the price is at the low end of my budget;
2) I can get it today and if there are any issues or I hate it, I can return it because it's GC (not as easy with other retailers or a private sale);
3) looking at the features it has, it seems to be a VERY viable candidate for the majority of what I'm looking for: small, capable, good reputation.

Once I get a chance to mess with it, I'll have a report. And it gets me into a baseline reading of knowing more of what I'd actually need (beyond the "nothing" I start with). As in, if I get this and realize there is a glaring omission of what I truly wanted to begin with, now I can narrow down a future selection by knowing what I need to look for.

Damn GAS! Always getting me in trouble... :woot:
Very much looking forward to your thoughts and opinions on this!
 
  • Like
Reactions: rojo412
First off, I honestly didn't know if "MISCELLANEOUS" was the place, but it could have been both right and wrong for "BASSES" or "EFFECTS", however it was slightly on topic, so... if it needs to be moved, please feel free!

I've recently become interested in getting an actual synth to add to my setup. It will not replace the bass, it would be a supplement to what I'm using, pretty much for punctuation and the kinds of things you'd hear for "temporary synth needs." A big intro note here and there, maybe some sound effects during a drum break, etc.

(and FWIW, I did do a search and only found threads from many years ago, so I'm pretty sure most of those recommendations are far outdated. Or at least, they don't contain stuff that would be more modern and readily available.)

THIS IS BASICALLY WHAT I'M AFTER:

- It must be a relatively small form factor, but with somewhat larger keys.
I had a MicroKorg and it's great, but the keys were narrower than my fingers would like. Function was perfect in many regards though! Just a bit small for me.
- It can't be expensive.
My gear money goes to basses. And while I realize this is "bass adjacent," if I had big money to spend on something, it's gonna be invested in a bass or rig that would get way more use. This project is essentially a small portion of what I would do, so I don't see a need to spend big money on it. If I become so infatuated with the art of doing it down the line, then yeah, I'll splurge... but this is my entry point. My max would be about $450 and that would only be if it's THAT good where I need to max out or it's just priced far lower than the true value.
- Not looking for anything too complex or involved.
I realize that I could get a controller and connect to a computer... but that is too much room for my practice area. I want just a keyboard that provides the bassier notes.
I also don't love learning to program patches or do anything where it requires being saved for presets and whatnot. I'd prefer something that can be manipulated manually for how I want it to sound and it will remain so until I change settings.
And finally, I don't play keys or piano, so it doesn't need to be a full piano. I prefer something small in width.
- If it could be connected to footpedals (ala "Poor man's Taurus"), that would be a bonus.
Yes, part of this desire has come from listening to 70s prog a bit and liking that ability. And yes, that adds complications to a degree. But if it becomes an option for me to do so down the line, the ability to make it actually work like that would be pretty cool, not gonna lie.

From what I've seen, there aren't a ton of different things that fit the bill and some do so better than others.
But I'd love to know what the actual TB bassists who do such dark arts are actually using and enjoying, as well as what they might steer me towards in a venture such as this.

So what should I be looking at first here?
You want SYNTH bass- meaning NOT keyboard electric bass sounds. You're in luck. Plenty on the market.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rojo412
While the time here has been short and I'm still learning, I would at least make these notes about the Monologue:

- The keys are still fairly small. While not the "baby teeth" that a MicroKorg uses, these are narrow. So if you're fatter fingered like me, you may still struggle a bit.
- This is yet another synth (and I assume MOST are like this) where even being labeled as somewhat "simple," it's got capabilities that I'd never quite reach for. There is a feeling that I am biting off more than I could chew in some ways, as it does require learning quite a bit to "make your own sound."
That said, you can find presets you like, modify them, then save them as your own separate preset pretty easily.
- Part of me is like "this is still fine. Make some things you like and save those and enjoy the damn thing!"
Another part of me is like "you're in over your head! Return this and get something simpler, you dolt!"
Fighting with myself can be sorta fun, I guess...

I'm no expert and I would definitely recommend this to someone who is looking for a lot of synth and arpeggiator capabilities in a very tidy package. It can sound absolutely massive and running it through some effects was even wilder. There isn't a ton to figure out, but it's still got a lot of things to figure out compared to a really basic, small electric piano.

Not that I'm any kind of keyboardist to begin with, but the short keyboard can kinda limit you (unless you're very deft with the octave lever), even if you're just going for the basic bass abilities. So unless you're looking to only have the range of most of the notes on a standard 4 string bass (which is 35 notes on a 20 fret neck) at your fingertips, you may want to at least look for a 37 key setup.
However, if only the money zone is your goal, this is more than adequate.

Now back to reading the manual, watching videos, and figuring out what to do for my band setup on Thursday.
 
The new Korg Multi/Poly Analog Modelling Synth. Can produce those classic bass sounds.

f4fbca6bf0323c638792a33788174464_pc.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eli_Kyiv
Okay... so they keep calling the Taktile a MIDI controller. And yeah, I see that.
What they aren't making abundantly clear to me (and this may be a stupid question), DOES IT WORK AS A STANDALONE?
Can I just plug it into an amp and make noises?
I don't see anything that suggests it can be used standalone.

Personally I could not tolerate the mishaps introduced from the use of a computer for sounds for frequent live use. I tried---perhaps too hard.
 
While the time here has been short and I'm still learning, I would at least make these notes about the Monologue:

- The keys are still fairly small. While not the "baby teeth" that a MicroKorg uses, these are narrow. So if you're fatter fingered like me, you may still struggle a bit.
- This is yet another synth (and I assume MOST are like this) where even being labeled as somewhat "simple," it's got capabilities that I'd never quite reach for. There is a feeling that I am biting off more than I could chew in some ways, as it does require learning quite a bit to "make your own sound."
That said, you can find presets you like, modify them, then save them as your own separate preset pretty easily.
- Part of me is like "this is still fine. Make some things you like and save those and enjoy the damn thing!"
Another part of me is like "you're in over your head! Return this and get something simpler, you dolt!"
Fighting with myself can be sorta fun, I guess...

I'm no expert and I would definitely recommend this to someone who is looking for a lot of synth and arpeggiator capabilities in a very tidy package. It can sound absolutely massive and running it through some effects was even wilder. There isn't a ton to figure out, but it's still got a lot of things to figure out compared to a really basic, small electric piano.

Not that I'm any kind of keyboardist to begin with, but the short keyboard can kinda limit you (unless you're very deft with the octave lever), even if you're just going for the basic bass abilities. So unless you're looking to only have the range of most of the notes on a standard 4 string bass (which is 35 notes on a 20 fret neck) at your fingertips, you may want to at least look for a 37 key setup.
However, if only the money zone is your goal, this is more than adequate.

Now back to reading the manual, watching videos, and figuring out what to do for my band setup on Thursday.

The Monologue is pretty awesome. I found these patches useful. This guy sort of gives you "bread and butter" sounds. And they aren't too spendy.:


Also, listening to the patch demos for different synths gives you a good idea what types of sounds you can get with different synths, so helps with shopping.

I eventually decided I play better on full-sized keys because there is more room to be sloppy without hitting an extra key. And if you play octaves a lot, it can get pretty interesting, although it helps immensely that the keyboard starts on E rather than C (unlike the bass-station). It also has a lot more character than the bass-station, which is good and bad. I don't know the technical terms, but I think the monologue has "slow envelopes", which makes it hard to get a "snappy" bass sound. Not a deal killer though. Our sound guy liked the sound so much he bought one!

Maybe we can make this a dedicated Synth Keyboard thread:

https://www.talkbass.com/threads/dedicated-synth-bass-forum.1662361/
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zbysek
I do appreciate all of everyone's feedback on this. And I hope in others' searches for info, this thread is helpful.

For me personally, I pretty much discovered that I'm just not a keyboard player myself, even if only for simple bass parts or accents.
I probably had it in my head to drop dome big, nasty booming synth bass in, ala Rush 80s or Genesis or whatever, where that Taurus punch really set some awesome tone. And I'd like to do that! But I have nowhere near the budget to even consider the midi controller/synth brain minimal setup required to make it happen.

I also managed to discover that the Source Audio C4 synth pedal is a phenomenal piece of gear to get all of those sounds and more with using a bass... but again, not my bailiwick. It was too much to process for my brain.

My best bet is some kind of simplistic funky pedal that does a bit more than just an envelope filter with dirt involved, but doesn't get to the point of a display with numbers, any presets, or programming capabilities.
But that's just me.

Again, I hope all that has been discussed here can also help people who entered into the same bit of GAS that I did, with more permanent and lasting results for them than me with my easily-overloaded brain. :thumbsup:
 
I don't see anything that suggests it can be used standalone.

Personally I could not tolerate the mishaps introduced from the use of a computer for sounds for frequent live use. I tried---perhaps too hard.

TRITON, unbound
A controller with the built-in sounds of the legendary workstation
- the new TRITON taktile​

I don't think it's multitimbral though... but for strictly bass synth it hardly matters.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KJMO
You're right, it does have 512 presets. Minimally editable, it wouldn't work for me, but it might work for someone. It seems mostly oriented toward being a controller, but maybe it has a couple good bass sounds. It reminds me of the stage pianos you can get with a few pianos, etc., but without the stage piano. I'd be interested to hear all the sounds.