I'll probably never have the opportunity to hear the competing systems in the same room. But I will say I've heard tremendous sound difference just by moving the sub a few feet or making EQ adjustments.
I'm just the "hobby bass player that cares about the overall sound so I do the sound, too" guy. It's all been a learning experience. I hated the mackie sub until we got mixers with HPF. Now I dig it. I'm only recently really starting to like our total sound, stage and FOH. The bass needs some mid boost because the PA stuff doesn't have the built in humps most bass cabs have.
Lately I've been placing my rig behind the drummer and me, barely turned up, with some bass in the monitors. It really fills up the stage without being loud. I dig what you're saying about not loud, but feelable. I've been saying that to the church sound guy for years.
We're more alike than different, that's for sure. I'm a bass player providing sound for my bands because I want us to sound good,too. I went from playing in clubs that always had their own sound to an area where it's all DIY. Hiring a sound guy is about $250 for someone who stands at the board the whole time and actually listens and makes adjustments. DJ's draw bigger crowds than bands around here and It's obvious that sound quality and consistency are major factors.
I'm also looking into a presonus mixer and from what I understand , it's now the easiest it's ever been to have great sound with these mixers because of the presets that are provided for different mic applications. The 16.0.2 is about a grand. Lol ! No racks to bring or nothing.
