I had the setup done at The Amp Shop\Bass Exchange in Sherman Oaks CA. Its an extremely reputable place, especially for bass. It's the only place in LA I know of that you can walk in and buy a Fodera, F-Bass or US Lakland off the wall. Given, everyone has a bad day every once in a while, but the tone wasn't quite right when I took it in.
It is used, so there could be some hidden issue that isn't immediately obvious; that's why I started the thread.
The other is because new German Warwicks are impossible to find, so I only have web videos and used dead-string beaters at GC to compare it too. I didn't know if there is something about these basses that is just darker tone-wise.