No I don’t. I do play the arrangement and serve the song. Within that there is plenty of space for my art.
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Songs you play wrong on purpose
- Thread starter DaveParker39
- Start date
No I don’t. I do play the arrangement and serve the song. Within that there is plenty of space for my art.
- Apr 18, 2008
- 16,007
- 1
- 31,701
- Disclosures
- I'm highly opinionated and extremely self-assured
All the time. Everything. I don’t subscribe to the “It should sound just like the record” ideology. It sounds like our rendition of a well-known song. And honestly, it never sounds exactly the same way twice!
This. I don't see what's on the record as sacred. Sometimes changes are required because of differences in instrumentation. Heck, even the band who recorded the record often don't play it note for note in a live concert.
Sometimes I just think that what's on the record was not the best choice of notes. If it's a cover song, I see no problem with either minor changes, but true to the original, or going into an all-out genre-bending original interpretation.
RE: "Play That Funky Music." I always felt that the riff in question just didn't sit right. I have always played it by doubling the vocal line.
John Paul Jones plays atonally in the guitar solo/jam part of Black Dog.
Most people don't notice, or wouldn't notice until I point it out to them.
Since I cover his work, I play it like that during the first time (it's a bigger stretch down to the F) thru, as a nod to JPJ. The second time thru, I go down to the G like I think most people would do.
JPJ does a lot of cool sheet that you only discover when you dig deep into his work. The isolated bass videos and stuff like that are cool for that.
Most people don't notice, or wouldn't notice until I point it out to them.
Since I cover his work, I play it like that during the first time (it's a bigger stretch down to the F) thru, as a nod to JPJ. The second time thru, I go down to the G like I think most people would do.
JPJ does a lot of cool sheet that you only discover when you dig deep into his work. The isolated bass videos and stuff like that are cool for that.
Hmmm... I can't think of one off-hand, but now I think should have one that I like to play my wrong way.
Like many others, I don't try to play note for note.
For one thing, I can't play everything the original artist did. For another, I don't care that I can't - I just need to play a decent bass line and hit the hooks in the music.
It's not wrong, it's my version.
For one thing, I can't play everything the original artist did. For another, I don't care that I can't - I just need to play a decent bass line and hit the hooks in the music.
It's not wrong, it's my version.
By wrongly, do you mean playing a song our own way? My band plays all our own songs live, but we have released a charity album of songs written by folk we know. All 25 are done our own way.
First tune that springs to mind... Margaritaville!
Most of the time I try to get the feel of a song, and show a little restraint. This has served me well, especially with country music. But if I'm required to play Margaritaville (thankfully a rare occurrence any more), I try to cram in pas many notes as humanly possible. That's the one song on which I allow myself a complete lack of taste. Forgive me, Jimmy Buffett! LOL
Most of the time I try to get the feel of a song, and show a little restraint. This has served me well, especially with country music. But if I'm required to play Margaritaville (thankfully a rare occurrence any more), I try to cram in pas many notes as humanly possible. That's the one song on which I allow myself a complete lack of taste. Forgive me, Jimmy Buffett! LOL
I play four kinds of songs:
Those I play wrong on purpose
Those I play wrong accidentally
Those I play right on purpose
Those I play right accidentally
Those I play wrong on purpose
Those I play wrong accidentally
Those I play right on purpose
Those I play right accidentally
Same here.
An example is REM's "The One I Love". When we first went to play it, I improvised a part from memory, which used a lot of the lead guitar riff. Afterwards I listened to and worked out how to play the correct bass part, as was actually recorded by the band.
But since then I've been playing a hybrid of both parts, which to my ears just sounds better than the recorded bass part alone.
Last edited:
Two Wrights make an airplane and three lefts make a right.
We recently added Burning Down the House. I love Tina, but she plays a bass synth on that and to me, it's one of her less interesting lines. Certainly has a cool little syncopated groove, but our keys player is not as funky as Bernie Worrell, so I've taken the following approach to the song: I stay fairly true to the bass line through the verses, but I added my Mutron for some squish, and I'm playing Bernie's synth solos. Just added it last weekend. I told them about the envelope filter, but I sprung the new riff on the gig, and drummer just looked at me, grinning. Keeper!
We use it as a vehicle for one of the guitar players to show off. I know he's gonna go on for a while, so I amuse myself by throwing in references to "Them Changes" and "Express Yourself."
I don’t strictly play covers but I do mix and match the lyrics of Light My Fire into Fire by Hendrix music. And so far nobody except the drummer ever commented on it.
Whenever somebody says "you're not playing it the way they did" I just say 'They didn't ask me how to play it, maybe both ways are right'
JeezyMcNuggles
Inactive
- Feb 23, 2018
- 14,723
- 20,970
- Disclosures
- I suck, but nobody really notices
I play things wrong on purpose to pass my guitar player off.
But, it's in key, and usually following the key boards. Just things that he wants me to follow him on instead. But, I just do it to make him mad.
"Oh yeah. My bad. I forgot."
Stay With Me - Faces.
Played this song with a group a few months ago. In the middle of the tune there are some very interesting "harmonization" choices with some of the notes on the bass guitar. When you play them note for note you sound like an idiot who keeps messing up the song.
Played this song with a group a few months ago. In the middle of the tune there are some very interesting "harmonization" choices with some of the notes on the bass guitar. When you play them note for note you sound like an idiot who keeps messing up the song.
