• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Squier CV Jazz or Vintage Modified jazz? Or MIM jazz?

I am going to save up for a jazz bass but I´m not sure which one.

Should I go with the Squier Classic Vibe Jazz, the Squier Vintage Modified jazz or a MIM jazz?

I used to have a Fender American Standard jazz several years ago which I liked a lot but it´s out of my price range right now.

Thanks for tips.

Best regards/Daniel
 
The MIM wouldn’t necessarily be the better instrument, but can be gotten used at a good price.

Some/many people care about the name on the headstock, which is fine, so I guess you’d have to evaluate yourself in that respect.

I know I have a MIM Jazz V that’s all set up, better pickups, my choice of strings, and I’m as happy as I can be...

and I kinda like the "Fender" on the headstock.


As for resale value, I’m guessing the MIM might be better, but I’m not positive about that.

:)
 
The MIM wouldn’t necessarily be the better instrument, but can be gotten used at a good price.

Some/many people care about the name on the headstock, which is fine, so I guess you’d have to evaluate yourself in that respect.

I know I have a MIM Jazz V that’s all set up, better pickups, my choice of strings, and I’m as happy as I can be...

and I kinda like the "Fender" on the headstock.


As for resale value, I’m guessing the MIM might be better, but I’m not positive about that.

:)

Thanks for your answer. To me it mean nothing what the headstock says. As long as the bass feels and sounds great.

I have a Squier Special 5 which I like a lot, but want a jazz body bass too.

As always it´s about finding the right bass by testing them. I would like it if I don´t have to uppgrade the bass the first thing I do. And I will get it setup for myself no mather which model I buy.

I would mostly want a 5-string bass and in that case it´s either a MIM or the new Vintage Modified 5.

Best regards/Daniel
 
Have you tried said basses?

I had a horrible experience with a MIM jazz bass standard...but I was pretty young...so it was probably not set up right, and even with a pickup change it never sounded right to my ears. Got a G&L Tribute, and it was 100000000000000 times better.

After all the fuzz about the squiers, I tried them out at GC, and I have to say I liked the Vintage Modified jazz bass A LOT! It just sounded very good from the get go! And wicked price too! The classic vibe I tried wasn't properly adjusted...so It wasn't as good as the VM.
 
Have you tried said basses?

I had a horrible experience with a MIM jazz bass standard...but I was pretty young...so it was probably not set up right, and even with a pickup change it never sounded right to my ears. Got a G&L Tribute, and it was 100000000000000 times better.

After all the fuzz about the squiers, I tried them out at GC, and I have to say I liked the Vintage Modified jazz bass A LOT! It just sounded very good from the get go! And wicked price too! The classic vibe I tried wasn't properly adjusted...so It wasn't as good as the VM.

Hello!

I have never tried these basses but I do have a Squier Special P which I like a lot. And I have had a Fender American Standard Jazz which I also liked a lot.

Glad to hear you liked the Vintage Modified a lot. I like the sound of it on some videos on youtube but I have to try one myself soon. Just hope the 5 string model of it is just as good as the 4 string model seems to be.

Best regards/Daniel
 
The MIM standards I have played have all been mediocre at best. Maybe I tried an unlucky few but I had more time enjoying the Classic vibe and vintage modified.

Thanks!

How big of a difference do you feel it is between the Classic Vibe and the Vintage Modified?

To bad there ain´t a 5 string version of the Classic Vibe. It looks good. But of course the Vintage Modified looks nice too.

Best regards/Daniel
 
Thanks!

How big of a difference do you feel it is between the Classic Vibe and the Vintage Modified?

To bad there ain´t a 5 string version of the Classic Vibe. It looks good. But of course the Vintage Modified looks nice too.

Best regards/Daniel
I found them both pretty solid I played only the jazz variation though I think the Classic Vibe sounds or plays a tiny bit better when set up right than Vintage Modified but I played more Vintage Modified basses that were set up to my liking. Granted I played 2 vintage and 3 classic. 2 being a friend and the others at retail shops.
 
I found them both pretty solid I played only the jazz variation though I think the Classic Vibe sounds or plays a tiny bit better when set up right than Vintage Modified but I played more Vintage Modified basses that were set up to my liking. Granted I played 2 vintage and 3 classic. 2 being a friend and the others at retail shops.

Okey!

Thanks.

Well I have to get to a store and try them out.

Best regards/Daniel
 
Personally I think the Classic Vibe is hands down the best bass of the lot. Just feels and sounds like a high class instrument. None of the MIM Standards I've played have done anything for me. The VM jazz isn't bad at all, but it tends to be on the really heavy side, which was a turn off for me.
 
That’s quite mature of you, and I wish I could say I cared “nothing” about the name on the headstock, but I do…

maybe just a *little*… but I do.

But even if you don’t care about that, maybe think of resale, or respect from other musicians (who aren’t as wise/educated as you), that “might” translate into an opportunity that does have some value to you.

I don’t know where you are in your music endeavors, but there are a lot of musicians who aren’t hip to the recent offerings, and it could be held against you.

Guitard/BL I’m with (not that it mattered in this case), when he first looked at my bass, I heard him mumble under his breath “Mexican”… what an ass, but that’s reality.

Not trying to talk you into/out of anything, just some thoughts.

That said, I have a Squier Affinity Jazz V, an on-line purchase, did nothing to it but add a tort pick guard for looks.

Certainly not as good as the Squiers you’re looking at, but it’s a wonderful bass, I’ve gigged it, and it’s the music-room beater now only because it’s the cheapest bass I have.

I guess what I’m trying to say is that, fair/reasonable or not, what’s on the headstock just might have some value, whether or not the letters mean anything to you personally.

If not, of course I expect you'll disregard everything I‘ve said.

:)
 
Personally I think the Classic Vibe is hands down the best bass of the lot. Just feels and sounds like a high class instrument. None of the MIM Standards I've played have done anything for me. The VM jazz isn't bad at all, but it tends to be on the really heavy side, which was a turn off for me.

Thanks for your input. I don´t mind heavy, but it´s worth thinking about. Maybe in a year or two I find it to heavy so it´s absolutely something to concider.

Best regards/Daniel

That’s quite mature of you, and I wish I could say I cared “nothing” about the name on the headstock, but I do…

maybe just a *little*… but I do.

But even if you don’t care about that, maybe think of resale, or respect from other musicians (who aren’t as wise/educated as you), that “might” translate into an opportunity that does have some value to you.

I don’t know where you are in your music endeavors, but there are a lot of musicians who aren’t hip to the recent offerings, and it could be held against you.

Guitard/BL I’m with (not that it mattered in this case), when he first looked at my bass, I heard him mumble under his breath “Mexican”… what an ass, but that’s reality.

Not trying to talk you into/out of anything, just some thoughts.

That said, I have a Squier Affinity Jazz V, an on-line purchase, did nothing to it but add a tort pick guard for looks.

Certainly not as good as the Squiers you’re looking at, but it’s a wonderful bass, I’ve gigged it, and it’s the music-room beater now only because it’s the cheapest bass I have.

I guess what I’m trying to say is that, fair/reasonable or not, what’s on the headstock just might have some value, whether or not the letters mean anything to you personally.

If not, of course I expect you'll disregard everything I‘ve said.

:)

Thanks for your thoughts. I get what you mean, and your probably right. And it´s something to concider.

About reselling!
These basses are so cheap so I´m probably not going to sell them. Might as well keep them. I have a couple of sons who like playing so in case I get to afford an American Fender I might as well give them the Squiers.

I have never met any musician who has talked down or even concidering talking down my instruments. But I guess there are idiots everywhere. In case someone would be disturbed that I play Squiers, then that person isn´t someone I would like to play with anyway.
As long as I sound good, play good and enjoy the bass that´s all that matters for me, and should be for anyone else too.

I am 35 years old. A drummer from the beginning. Have played drums for about 20 years and bass for about 10 years. I have been sponsored before. Have played Larriveé, Yamaha, Fender and a lot of other basses. Both 4, 5 and 6 strings. So I´m a little too old to let someone trashtalk me because of what instrument I play;)

But again, I see what you mean and I thank you for your input.

Take care.

Best regards/Daniel
 
I have a VM Jazz. I love it!! I compared the CV jazz, the Geddy jazz, and the VM. The CV, to me, didn't feel right. I wasn't a fan of the gloss finish on the neck and the sound wasn't what I was looking for. The Geddy Lee was AMAZING!!!! But out of my price range. The VM felt like home the frist time I played it. I loved the the block and bound natural neck and the maple body just has that funky vibe to it. Plus with the bridge Pup, being closer to the bridge, I am able to get a nice growl; which a jazz bass NEEDS to have.
So I got the VM threw on a Badass II bridge, same as the Geddy, and I couldn't be happier.

I couldn't careless about resale value, it is a bass not a freakin car, or how I am looked at because I have a "low end" bass.
My "low end" budget bass can kick the crap out of your "high end" expensive bass, IN MY HANDS!
 
The "CV vs MIM" and "CV vs VM" thing has been done to death, but since you asked for opinions...

IMO, and if you're buying new, the CV is the better of the three in terms of value. I've played a lot of CVs that were on par with their MIM counterparts. Is a good MIM nicer than a good CV? Perhaps, but for my dollar, it's not $200-$250 nicer. In the bang-for-the-buck category, the MIMs leave me flat.

The VMs are not bad basses - as a matter of fact, I usually like the VM necks more than I do the CV necks. In terms of build quality and hardware, the CVs edge out the VMs, but they do cost a bit more. If you want the glossy neck finish, an upgraded bridge and different pickups, then the $50 extra for a CV would be money well spent. Otherwise, you can pick up a new VM for $300 and play happily ever after.

If you're buying used, a decent MIM can be found around or under $300, which makes it a better value. Again, IMO, IME, just my 2 cents, etc., etc..

For further reading:

http://www.talkbass.com/forum/f8/fender-vs-squier-what-your-opinions-795812/

http://www.talkbass.com/forum/f8/squier-vintage-modified-classic-vibe-782984/

http://www.talkbass.com/forum/f8/squier-classic-vibe-jazz-vs-squier-vintage-modified-jazz-658861/

http://www.talkbass.com/forum/f8/classic-vibe-vintage-modified-663963/

http://www.talkbass.com/forum/f8/squier-vintage-modified-vs-classic-vibe-j-bass-627540/

http://www.talkbass.com/forum/f8/vintage-modified-vs-classic-vibe-622301/

http://www.talkbass.com/forum/f8/squier-vintage-modified-squier-classic-vibe-series-481126/
 
I picked up a 77 Squier VM and I thew a set of KEnt Armtrong lipsticks in it. Holy mother does that thing have an awesome growl. Will be posting pics in the tricked out Squier thread son. I would put any of my VM's (I have 2) up against a MIM Fender. I played a Fender V a couple of days ago and it felt cheaper than the affinity Jazz that I used to have.

I have to admit I am Squierphobic when it comes to the name on the headstock. But hearing these puppies play and how they sound, I am considering trading my more expensive BTB on a five sting VM. I also think it would be cool to hear some gear snobs say "Holy S#!T that's a Squier!!!!!"
 
Give the Squiers serious consideration--a lot of bass for the money. What kind of music do you play? A Geddy, or any JB with a BadAss or other hi-gh mass bridge, will give an aggressive attack perfect for metal or hard rock. I have a Geddy and switched out the BAII for a vintage bass. I settled down quite a bit. My kid even likes it and he plays grindcore. Go figure.
 
Squier Classic Vibe is my suggestion, unless you just really prefer maple fretboards, then it's a toss up between the Squier VM & Fender MIM. Both are great choices, but I'd give the edge to the Squier VM.

In all honestly, you can either of your 3 choices used for $250, but if my vote had any say (most likely it doesn't): I'd still recommend the Squier CV. From my experience with it, they're beauties and fantastic players, basswood bodies with glossy necks, vintage frets and superb playability.

I feel a bit of regret selling mine off, but who am I kidding, I'm a P-bass guy after it's all said and done. :bassist: