TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
AFAIK, only in a few cases is this true.Squier J bass' pups, both bridge and neck, are the same size. MIM Fender basses are the same way. MIA J bass' bridge pup is slightly longer than the neck pup. So, it depends.
If the pickup's dead, no reason why you can't change it, just make sure the pickup is the proper width (as stated above). Fenders and Squiers from a certain era (and made in Mexico) used to have equal-sized pickups in the neck and bridge, while those outside that era and/or not made in Mexico had normal, proportional-sized pickups.
If you don't want to spend a lot, you can give GFS pickups a shot. They are cheap, yet a lot of people like their sound. Before you buy a new one, tell us, does the bridge PU give out any sound at all when you turn it up and mute the neck PU? Does it crackle and buzz?
Squier J bass' pups, both bridge and neck, are the same size. MIM Fender basses are the same way. MIA J bass' bridge pup is slightly longer than the neck pup. So, it depends.
The Squier pickups are quite good - you can save a lot of $$ by just finding a used replacement one. Just be sure it is the right length.