• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Tal Wilkenfeld...maybe I'm missing something...

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm not making assumptions about anything..I know what I hear..
I've been following Jeff Becks music for almost as long as I've been playing myself.
I want to hear "the best" from him..
I just don't think Tal is quite up to his par is all I'm sayin'

I've heard him with solid, workmanlike, but unspectacular bassists before (Randy Hope-Taylor and Mo Foster come to mind). Both of them are two of the finest session bassists in the UK, and they played the gig perfectly and didn't grandstand Beck.
A very young Fernando Saunders (with the Jan Hammer Group) was in much the same position as Tal in 1976 and he's done all right for himself ;)
I have a live recording of Stanley with Jeff and it seems a mismatch-2 great players and leaders trying to lead simultaneously. Interesting.....
 
I've heard him with solid, workmanlike, but unspectacular bassists before (Randy Hope-Taylor and Mo Foster come to mind). Both of them are two of the finest session bassists in the UK, and they played the gig perfectly and didn't grandstand Beck.
A very young Fernando Saunders (with the Jan Hammer Group) was in much the same position as Tal in 1976 and he's done all right for himself ;)
I have a live recording of Stanley with Jeff and it seems a mismatch-2 great players and leaders trying to lead simultaneously. Interesting.....

I sure enjoy 2 players playing "off of" each other and spurring it on..To each his own i guess..
I wouldn't want to hear Jeff "playin' it safe"
That's not what his stuff is about..Again IMO
 
I've heard him with solid, workmanlike, but unspectacular bassists before (Randy Hope-Taylor and Mo Foster come to mind). Both of them are two of the finest session bassists in the UK, and they played the gig perfectly and didn't grandstand Beck.
A very young Fernando Saunders (with the Jan Hammer Group) was in much the same position as Tal in 1976 and he's done all right for himself ;)
I have a live recording of Stanley with Jeff and it seems a mismatch-2 great players and leaders trying to lead simultaneously. Interesting.....

Also Jeff Beck with Pino Palladino a few years back.
 
I sure enjoy 2 players playing "off of" each other and spurring it on..To each his own i guess..
I wouldn't want to hear Jeff "playin' it safe"
That's not what his stuff is about..Again IMO

In each of those cases Jeff had a different sparring partner (Tony Hymas, Jan Hammer, and interestingly enough Jennifer Batten) that was his primary foil and the bass was just doing what a bass does most of the time and taking care of business. Interestingly, Phil Chen and Wilbur Bascomb, the bassists on Wired and Blow by Blow come more from the session world and out of the Motown tradition and less from Jazz/Fusion.
I guess the best chemistry with a bassist as the sparring partner was the old Beck, Bogert and Appice, but that was a volatile mixture that didn't last long.
 
I sure liked Beck, Bogert and Appice....
Even with the more traditional guys...Just felt like it flowed more...not forced...
That may be a generational thing-as in one of my earlier posts one of the sad things about the Music Business today is that there is no Music Farm Team system and no way to apprentice-really talented players are going from the woodshed to Youtube to really visible gigs and Music Press with no seasoning.
Billy Sheehan played 3,000 gigs with Talas before anyone knew who he was. I learned how to play recording sessions on countless bad Custom Albums and songwriter demos before everyone put Pro Tools in their homes and went DIY. Younger players just don't have that opportunity.
Actually, Tal, Hadrian, Damian, Matt, and countless other fine young talents are in their apprenticeships right now-it just wasn't such a public process 30 years ago.
 
That may be a generational thing-as in one of my earlier posts one of the sad things about the Music Business today is that there is no Music Farm Team system and no way to apprentice-really talented players are going from the woodshed to Youtube to really visible gigs and Music Press with no seasoning.
Billy Sheehan played 3,000 gigs with Talas before anyone knew who he was. I learned how to play recording sessions on countless bad Custom Albums and songwriter demos before everyone put Pro Tools in their homes and went DIY. Younger players just don't have that opportunity.

Very true!
Saw Billy with Talas...Mind blowing back then!
 
Anyone look at Jeff Becks website? He has a totally new band line-up for the 2010 World Tour. Rhonda Smith has the gig.

http://www.jeffbeck.com/

Rhonda has the JB gig? Wow, good for her. For those who don't know, Rhonda did some fantastic jazz fusion stuff with a band called The Merlin Factor before she got the gig with Prince. I can see her fitting the bill very well. Does make me wonder whether JB is on a female bassist kick right now though...
 
Rhonda has the JB gig? Wow, good for her. For those who don't know, Rhonda did some fantastic jazz fusion stuff with a band called The Merlin Factor before she got the gig with Prince. I can see her fitting the bill very well. Does make me wonder whether JB is on a female bassist kick right now though...

I very glad for her. Rhonda has been working her butt off for years. Think she will make a good compliment to Jeff. She has a ton of soul and funk going on as well as the fusion thing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.