• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

TB Fantasy League?

No I didn't name it. The manager just says "A Yahoo User" so I don't know.
I'm all for funny rules. I have more standard leagues so I am up for messing with this one. Let's say 2 QBS for sure at 10 teams (where we are now). I still don't know about 12. Anyone up for points for completions?

I added a DB, DL, and LB in addition to a D/ST.
 
I'm down for points for completions...we play that way in my money league. I'm not really interested in individual defensive positions though. It's a little too much work. I'd take 2 Defensive teams, and 2 kickers though. I'd also add a flex spot as well. So 2 qb, 2 rbs, 3 wrs, 1 te and 1 flex.
 
I'm down for points for completions...we play that way in my money league. I'm not really interested in individual defensive positions though. It's a little too much work. I'd take 2 Defensive teams, and 2 kickers though. I'd also add a flex spot as well. So 2 qb, 2 rbs, 3 wrs, 1 te and 1 flex.
Alright. D Players have been nuked. I added a second D/ST and 1 W/R/T and 1 W/R/T/QB. How does that sound? That way if your best QB2 option is Rex Grossman you can play a WR instead.
 
Alright. D Players have been nuked. I added a second D/ST and 1 W/R/T and 1 W/R/T/QB. How does that sound? That way if your best QB2 option is Rex Grossman you can play a WR instead.
Not sure a QB should be allowed in a flex spot. I meant just WR or RB. Usually QB's score the most points so that would promote QB hoarding at the draft. I'd certainly draft that way if I could have 3 qb's playing.
 
Not sure a QB should be allowed in a flex spot. I meant just WR or RB. Usually QB's score the most points so that would promote QB hoarding at the draft. I'd certainly draft that way if I could have 3 qb's playing.

I think a handful of Qb's score the most points, the rest put up WR3 numbers.... Just a thought. I can change any and everything. Don't really care either way.

We are at 2 QB and one flex right now. If we end with 10 teams I will add another Flex, if we have 12 I may just leave it.
 
I think a handful of Qb's score the most points, the rest put up WR3 numbers.... Just a thought. I can change any and everything. Don't really care either way.

We are at 2 QB and one flex right now. If we end with 10 teams I will add another Flex, if we have 12 I may just leave it.
All I'm saying is that if an RB or WR scores in proportion to a QB then it could be OK. If QB score disproportionate to other positions, it could be unfair/lopsided.
 
All I'm saying is that if an RB or WR scores in proportion to a QB then it could be OK. If QB score disproportionate to other positions, it could be unfair/lopsided.
Yeah I've been looking at the stats... It's not as wide a margin as you might think but on average QB is the highest point total position. Interesting stuff though. And it depends on your scoring methodology. I could easily handicap a QB down to RB/WR levels of production.
 
Yeah I've been looking at the stats... It's not as wide a margin as you might think but on average QB is the highest point total position. Interesting stuff though. And it depends on your scoring methodology. I could easily handicap a QB down to RB/WR levels of production.
You're the commish - your call.

I'm only trying to avoid a situation where hoarding becomes a problem. If I can play 3qb's and they on average score more, I'll be hoarding myself, for sure.