pardon my french, but HoLy poopie
DUDE! I'm incredibly impressed, and I don't get impressed (honestly impressed) like this very often any more.
I'm working on learning this song (all the parts (bass, guitar, drums, keys- I'm a masochist), to record for my many years in the making solo album).... and I actually just learned a few things from watching you play this that will help me immensely!
Also - DAMN I CAN FINALLY HEAR THE BASS PART ON A DREAM THEATER ALBUM!
hahaha
I HATE how they mix the bass so scooped and fuzzy and quiet on their albums, nice tone, but just disappears.
your tone has presence, and was played INSANELY well.
I'm just blown away.
Also, I owned one of those basses briefly and just couldn't handle it - high action that I just couldn't bring down low enough even with a huge (HUGE) shim in the pocket, and the tone just never worked for me. Yours sounds like that, but you definitely make it work for you... I can hear the lack of presence and treble that I encountered, but you work around it, presumably using your tc nova system eq etc.
End result is great - my new favorite version of the song. Turning this into an mp3 for myself to learn the part from LoL
Wow man, love your playing, taste, accuracy, sound... humor LoL, well done!
Well, thank you, DKelley!
I appreciate the time you took to check it out. I used to play this in my former band (we were me, drums, keys and were in-between guitarists) when we worked it up. Took about 2 years, but we had the drums, keys and bass down cold. The guitarist we eventually got was a bit intimidated by it and never really took to it, so we stopped playing it very frequently, to my dismay.
I picked it up again recently because I wanted to cover "Instrumedley" from the Budokan DVD (yes, I too, and all prog bassists, are masochists at heart). Much of it I knew from covering "Dance of Eternity," "Erotomania," "Ytse Jam," "Paradigm Shift," "Metropolis Part I," and "Universal Mind." So I figured I knew about 95% of "Instrumedley" and that it would be easy.
WRONG 10000x
"Instrumedley" comes at you anywhere from 5% to 25% faster than the studio versions of the songs that comprise it - it's insane. So while I knew "Dance," the end of "Instrumedley" before they close with "Hell's Kitchen" where they revive it after the LTE stuff, I could not play it at the DVD tempo without slopping up on some of those 10-note half step runs lol. So I figured I would fix that by slowing it down... but then I remembered that "Dance" is slower tempo than "Instrumedley" - so why not revisit "Dance" and do a video, using it as a springboard for "Instrumedley"? "Dance" helped me get the song under my fingers, because the better I know a piece the faster I can play it without getting too sloppy. It's when I come to apart where it's not rock solid in muscle memory, and since I can't really read I have to learn the entire song by memory because I can't refer to a score as Im going to check myself, I don't have any choice but to remember everything start to finish.
There are some definite gonks - an extra note near the end of the bass solo, a few notes are a bit late because of the difficulty in making the reaches at that speed, or the complexity of the pattern. For instance, John plays a fretted "D" in places where I may hit an open string "D," causing my note to lose some character when compared to how he hits it, but it was either that or miss the riff entirely, so here and there is a nip and a tuck.
Anyhow, thank you again.
I am singularly IMPRESSED that a single person would become 4 of the best musicians on the planet in playing one of their most difficult pieces! Bass, guitar, drums AND keys? Do you know how astounding a split screen video would be??? I would freakin love to see that. Unfreakn real.
I'd love to see it - do you have a Youtube channel or anything?
About the bass - You're right about the tone. On it's own the RBXJM2 doesn't have a lot of presence and some high end shimmer that I would like, and you're also correct that I compensate for it with the Nova System parametric EQ. I also have to change the strings frequently as I use a lot of Dunlop string cleaner to lube the strings AND my plucking fingers. The stuff is magic. I will apply it directly to my plucking hand fingertips before a song.
Glad you enjoyed the vid - let me know about the progress you make on an incredible challenge. Wow.
\M/