Technically it could still be an amp-side problem as it's not sensing the resistor-ladder changes/sending the LED voltage, but that is pretty unlikely. Zooming in I see at least one diode of some sort, so there's a few more parts to that circuit than JUST a resistor ladder it seems, but still looks pretty basic/simple based on the visible PBC traces.Hey, once again I really appreciate all the help you gave me with this. I can at least rest assured that it’s not coming from the amp itself, so I’ll pick up a multimeter and take it from there, meaning I’ll most likely end up taking you up on the offer.
have a great rest of your evening/morning and an even better tomorrow.
I don't think you should have to unsolder anything to look at more stuff. Those footswitches should come off the faceplate somehow, whether a nut on the front side or a spring retention on the back side I'd hope. It'd be pretty weird to have 'permenant' installed footswitches, but who knows what crazy engineers might do sometimes

I will warn, if you have to start unsoldering stuff I'd stop before doing that and hit me up. At that point you could do more damage from unsoldering without the right tools (my desoldering gun alone was ~$250).
Have a good evening and happy holidays!