• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join free Log in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

The Best Bass - a game

Status
Not open for further replies.
#221
14 Bee
10 Benavente
15 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
17 Fender
2 Gibson +
16 Ibanez
19 Lakland
11 Modulus
8 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
23 Spector
3 Traben -
20 Yamaha

0 Warwick
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX

*Liko's post showed two (-) and two (+). I couldn't tell if it was an actual overvote, so I restored Gibson.

bbates77 - if I made an error in the adjustment, please correct the mistake. Thanks!;)
 
#222
14 Bee
10 Benavente
15 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
17 Fender
2 Gibson
16 Ibanez
19 Lakland
12 Modulus +
8 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
23 Spector
2 Traben -
20 Yamaha

0 Warwick
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
 
#224
14 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
15 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
17 Fender
16 Ibanez
19 Lakland
12 Modulus
8 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
23 Spector
2 Traben
21 Yamaha +

0 Warwick
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson -
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
 
#225
14 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
15 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
16 Fender -
16 Ibanez
19 Lakland
12 Modulus
8 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
23 Spector
2 Traben
21 Yamaha
1 Gibson +


0 Warwick
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
 
#226
14 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
15 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
15 Fender -
16 Ibanez
19 Lakland
12 Modulus
8 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
23 Spector
2 Traben
21 Yamaha
2 Gibson +


0 Warwick
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
 
#228
funkybassplayer said:
kevinator, once the brand gets to zero it goes in the bottom list and stays there. you don't put it back up top. i tried to do the same thing with warwick. Read the first post on this thread.
Click to expand...

Thanks - I'll put it back to 0.:hiding:
I guess I didn't read the rules carefully. Maybe there should have been a 1 vote each rule. Too bad 1 or 2 people can knock an excellent brand out by voting against it 5 times or more; kind of like the reviewers on MF who have "heard about it" and give an instrument a bad rating. Well at least Gibson is in good company in the '0' list with Warwick (who'd of thunk?).
 
#229
14 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
15 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
15 Fender -
16 Ibanez
19 Lakland
12 Modulus
8 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
23 Spector
2 Traben
21 Yamaha


0 Gibson
0 Warwick
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
 
#230
14 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
15 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
15 Fender
16 Ibanez
19 Lakland
13 Modulus +
8 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
23 Spector
1 Traben -
21 Yamaha


0 Gibson
0 Warwick
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
 
#231
funkybassplayer said:
14 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
15 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
15 Fender
16 Ibanez
19 Lakland
13 Modulus +
8 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
23 Spector
1 Traben -
21 Yamaha


0 Gibson
0 Warwick
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
Click to expand...

14 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
15 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
15 Fender
17 Ibanez +
19 Lakland
13 Modulus
8 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
23 Spector
21 Yamaha

0 Traben -
0 Gibson
0 Warwick
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
 
#233
14 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
16 Carvin +
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
15 Fender
17 Ibanez
19 Lakland
13 Modulus
7 Mosrite -
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
23 Spector
21 Yamaha

0 Traben
0 Gibson
0 Warwick
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
 
#234
Hawaii Islander said:
14 Bee

*Liko's post showed two (-) and two (+). I couldn't tell if it was an actual overvote, so I restored Gibson.

bbates77 - if I made an error in the adjustment, please correct the mistake. Thanks!;)
Click to expand...

Sorry, I haven't been checking the thread lately (Spector's kept a good posi.)

Yes the adjustment was correct however in thread #218 there was an overvote and because the "You get to vote ONE +1 point and ONE -1 point PER DAY" rule was broken I'm going to reverse the votes:

Gibson was already adjusted by Hawaii Islander so Gibson remains at 0.
Carvin +1
Fender -1
Yamaha -1

0's back in alphabetic order

14 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
17 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender
17 Ibanez
19 Lakland
13 Modulus
7 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
23 Spector
20 Yamaha

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick
 
#235
Kelvinator said:
Thanks - I'll put it back to 0.:hiding:
I guess I didn't read the rules carefully. Maybe there should have been a 1 vote each rule. Too bad 1 or 2 people can knock an excellent brand out by voting against it 5 times or more; kind of like the reviewers on MF who have "heard about it" and give an instrument a bad rating. Well at least Gibson is in good company in the '0' list with Warwick (who'd of thunk?).
Click to expand...

This is a game, not an open review. Your welcome to create your own...actually, that'd be a good idea.

This is my post:

14 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
17 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender
17 Ibanez
19 Lakland
13 Modulus
7 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
24 Spector +
19 Yamaha -

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick
 
#236
14 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
17 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender
17 Ibanez
19 Lakland
14 Modulus +
7 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
17 Rickenbacker -
13 Roscoe
24 Spector
19 Yamaha

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick
 
#237
14 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
18 Carvin +
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender
17 Ibanez
19 Lakland
14 Modulus
7 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
17 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha -

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick
 
#239
15 Bee
9 Benavente-
10 Birdsong
18 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
13 Fender
17 Ibanez
19 Lakland
14 Modulus
7 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker +
13 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick
 
#240
15 Bee
9 Benavente-
10 Birdsong
18 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
13 Fender
17 Ibanez
19 Lakland
14 Modulus
7 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
17 Rickenbacker -
13 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
1 Warwick+

*sob* you're all so mean to the Warwicks!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Top Bottom
Back