The Best Bass - a game

[Hawaii Islander]

15 Bee
9 Benavente
10 Birdsong
18 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender +
17 Ibanez
18 Lakland -
14 Modulus
7 Mosrite
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[James Hart]

15 Bee
10 Benavente +
10 Birdsong
18 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender
17 Ibanez
18 Lakland
14 Modulus
6 Mosrite -
21 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[bbates77]

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
1 Warwick+

*sob* you're all so mean to the Warwicks!

Unfortunately as per the rules Warwick cannot be revived. You are welcome to vote again today and make another + and - vote for a bass not listed as 0.

 

[ROON]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
18 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender
17 Ibanez
18 Lakland
14 Modulus
5 Mosrite -
22 Musicman +
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[bbates77]

kevinator, once the brand gets to zero it goes in the bottom list and stays there. you don't put it back up top. i tried to do the same thing with warwick. Read the first post on this thread.

Thanks - I'll put it back to 0.
I guess I didn't read the rules carefully. Maybe there should have been a 1 vote each rule. Too bad 1 or 2 people can knock an excellent brand out by voting against it 5 times or more; kind of like the reviewers on MF who have "heard about it" and give an instrument a bad rating. Well at least Gibson is in good company in the '0' list with Warwick (who'd of thunk?).

This is a game, not an open review. Your welcome to create your own...actually, that'd be a good idea.

Guess what guys, I've done it. I've created a formal review in the Basses forum, check it out:

http://www.talkbass.com/forum/showthread.php?p=4703617#post4703617

 

[hawaiianbass]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
19 Carvin +
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender
17 Ibanez
18 Lakland
14 Modulus
4 Mosrite -
22 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
13 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[funkybassplayer]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
19 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender
17 Ibanez
18 Lakland
14 Modulus
3 Mosrite -
22 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe +
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[hawaiianbass]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
20 Carvin +
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender
17 Ibanez
18 Lakland
14 Modulus
2 Mosrite -
22 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[kbr]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
20 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender
18 Ibanez +
18 Lakland
14 Modulus
2 Mosrite
22 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[hawaiianbass]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
21 Carvin +
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender
18 Ibanez
18 Lakland
14 Modulus
1 Mosrite -
22 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[funkybassplayer]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
21 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender
18 Ibanez
18 Lakland
15 Modulus +
22 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 Mosrite -
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[hawaiianbass]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
22 Carvin +
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
14 Fender
18 Ibanez
18 Lakland
14 Modulus -
22 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 Mosrite
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[Hawaii Islander]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
22 Carvin
11 Conklin
13 Dingwall
15 Fender +
18 Ibanez
17 Lakland -
14 Modulus
22 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 Mosrite
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[funkybassplayer]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
22 Carvin
10 Conklin -
13 Dingwall
15 Fender
18 Ibanez
17 Lakland
15 Modulus +
22 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 Mosrite
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[ROON]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
9 Birdsong -
22 Carvin
10 Conklin
13 Dingwall
15 Fender
18 Ibanez
17 Lakland
15 Modulus
23 Musicman +
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 Mosrite
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[BassManPatsFan]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong +
22 Carvin
10 Conklin
13 Dingwall
15 Fender
18 Ibanez
17 Lakland
15 Modulus
22 Musicman -
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 Mosrite
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[Hawaii Islander]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
22 Carvin
10 Conklin
13 Dingwall
16 Fender +
18 Ibanez
16 Lakland -
15 Modulus
22 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 Mosrite
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[funkybassplayer]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
22 Carvin
09 Conklin -
13 Dingwall
16 Fender
18 Ibanez
16 Lakland
16 Modulus +
22 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 Mosrite
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[hawaiianbass]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
23 Carvin +
09 Conklin
13 Dingwall
16 Fender
18 Ibanez
16 Lakland
15 Modulus -
22 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe
24 Spector
18 Yamaha

0 Mosrite
0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

 

[bbates77]

15 Bee
10 Benavente
10 Birdsong
23 Carvin
09 Conklin
13 Dingwall
16 Fender
18 Ibanez
16 Lakland
15 Modulus
22 Musicman
20 Peavey
11 Pedulla
18 Rickenbacker
14 Roscoe
25 Spector +
17 Yamaha -

0 BC Rich
0 ESP
0 Gibson
0 Jackson
0 Mosrite
0 Rogue
0 Schecter
0 SX
0 Traben
0 Warwick

I just love how no-one's minusing Spector