• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

The hospital emergency room.

I got into a fistfight once. My nose was broken and my glasses were shattered and I had shards of lens in my eyes. (Not a violent guy...it was the first and last major fight in my life) Took 7 hours for someone to see me.

You'd think my blood soaked face and clothes and temporary blindness would have been enough to get me to the front of the line, but apparently not.

I have no idea what the guidelines for emergency room order of urgency protocols are, but they could probably use some rethinking.

Triage guidelines are formalized and documented. To determine if you were not seen timely ,a review of the patients seen before you since your arrival charts would have to be done to determine if you were correctly prioritized. There limits to resources in every organization and yes bloody clothes and temporary blindness do not move ahead of heart failure, or head wounds. for example, depending on how deep your cuts were an infant with a temperature of 104 or greater is at much more risk than you were.
 
Using emergency facilities for non-emergency general practitioner patient care is a well-established resource suck, time-consuming, inefficient, and expensive for hospitals, and something that should have been addressed long ago.

I'll say it---our medical care system definitely needed some oversight, and I don't think anyone of any affiliation denied that reality. The question is: Did we do it the right way? Only time will tell.

I hope your dad's okay Mike.

Government caused the problem in the first place with EMTALA. Obamacare has nothing to do with providing access and better care. All that had to be done was extend the reach of Medicare and Medicaid so all are insured.
 
There are also urgent care centers for non emergeny but needy treatment. The center my insurance covers is kind of iffy.
Invalid Link Removed

Urgent care centers are awesome minimal wait and more convenient hours. Again these fall outside of EMTALA regulations so showing up there without cash, credit card, or insurance will get you referred to the free clinic or ER
 
IDK, for every day pains, the current OTCs are adequate. Stronger pain should still require the supervision of a physician. I've known enough pill poppers that legalizing it probably won't solve anything.

Cool site. Check it out. Compare the US and Canada to say, South Africa. And that's when Ginger Baker was living there.

The cats out of the bag. I may be wrong but it's my understanding that 90% of the oxycodone consumption world wide is North American.

Might as well keep the addicts off the street. Or give them a safe place to cop until they choose to OD.

Invalid Link Removed
 
That's because they let the most expensive patients die. That whole you have served your useful purpose bit.

Another factor is some socialized medicine does not adopt certain technology's based on their cost.

When I was in Turkey they, the natives, told me to make sure I didn't get in an accident. It's much cheaper to let you stay in one place rather than transport you to the hospital.

I tell people when they travel to foreign lands to keep in mind they are not in America.

The typical response it " But I'm an American Citizen!"
 
Cool site. Check it out. Compare the US and Canada to say, South Africa. And that's when Ginger Baker was living there.

The cats out of the bag. I may be wrong but it's my understanding that 90% of the oxycodone consumption world wide is North American.

Might as well keep the addicts off the street. Or give them a safe place to cop until they choose to OD.

Invalid Link Removed

Oxy is pretty cheap as is. The problem is that ya need more and more. Even without a prescription it would cost money.

The cost from constant overdoses would add up quickly. Accidental or not.
 
I will say, any time I have gone to the hospital in an ambulance, I haven't had to wait behind any of those "I don't feel good" folks; priority service, every time.



I've never been in any condition to gloat while there, but in hindsight it makes me feel like the 911 call was worth it.


NO! Just no. Sorry, that is not how health care works, you categorically do not get seen quicker for turning up in an ambulance- I'm confident even applying that to America. Though you clearly were in need of an ambulance.

Speaking as an emergency call taker for the Ambulance service (somewhere in England, I shan't say where) you would genuinely be baffled by what people call us for. Just today I took a call from someone requesting an ambulance for toothache.
I'm not sure if you got that TOOTHACHE. Called an AMBULANCE....

Having see the dentist earlier today and been given antibiotics that "aren't working".

Man, I could tell some stories. The things I hear. Today is also known as mad/ black eye Friday.

It's a sad state of affairs that people these days don't know what an emergency is, don't understand their own healthcare and unfortunately a large proportion of people not only have no education on how healthcare facilities work or what triage is but are so involved in their own bubbles that they think their insignificant little medical incident (broken nail etc) is not only an emergency but THE emergency and more important than anyone else.
But I love my job. Genuinely.
 
Okay, an idea about ER's. You'll never overcome the fact that people trust an ER to be a place where they can get any kind of care no matter what's wrong with them, regardless of their financial situation or IQ. Build a primary care facility adjacent to each ER, and divert incoming patients as they walk in the door.

About non-payment: Everybody should be covered by employer based insurance, exchange based, or Medicaid.

Another idea: As health care becomes more standardized, add "how to deal with health care" to the high school curriculum. There should be a catch-all class in how to survive as an adult, which includes personal health and finance.
 
That's because they let the most expensive patients die. That whole you have served your useful purpose bit.

Another factor is some socialized medicine does not adopt certain technology's based on their cost.

I have seen some very expensive patients that were long since brain dead that we kept alive for years. I think in these extreme cases, the hospital stopped getting reimbursement about a year and a half in.
 
Okay, an idea about ER's. You'll never overcome the fact that people trust an ER to be a place where they can get any kind of care no matter what's wrong with them, regardless of their financial situation or IQ. Build a primary care facility adjacent to each ER, and divert incoming patients as they walk in the door.

About non-payment: Everybody should be covered by employer based insurance, exchange based, or Medicaid.

Another idea: As health care becomes more standardized, add "how to deal with health care" to the high school curriculum. There should be a catch-all class in how to survive as an adult, which includes personal health and finance.


If we turn away non emergency cases they'll learn in no time.

Problem solved. And it's free!

And with many people failing to make it though high school I can't see your Master Plan working very well.

Just my opinion.

Let people learn the hard way. They tend to remember better.
 
I have seen some very expensive patients that were long since brain dead that we kept alive for years. I think in these extreme cases, the hospital stopped getting reimbursement about a year and a half in.
It saddens me that you're at a level where you have access to this information, yet haven't heard of basic cost reduction measures that are widespread in the business world.
 
Oh wise oracle of business, tell us how to make trauma centers and ghetto hospitals profitable. Inquiring minds want to know.
It might not be possible to make those institutions profitable, but profit is neither a goal nor a guarantee that I've offered. Not all businesses succeed. And private ownership of hospitals in high poverty areas isn't an idea that I've even advocated.

My hope is for a nationwide health care system that costs less while delivering better care. Lower cost means somebody makes less money. I can't tell you that something will be cheaper and more profitable at the same time.

As for saying exactly what to do, that can't be an expectation of an informal discussion, because none of us are content matter experts, yet we are free to discuss issues anyway. And in my case, I'm hampered by the fact that what I advocate starts with gathering information:

Where is the money going?

Are you opposed to this? Why?

Where is the money going?
 
I have seen some very expensive patients that were long since brain dead that we kept alive for years. I think in these extreme cases, the hospital stopped getting reimbursement about a year and a half in.

Yes I was responding to the "low" cost comment of someone. But yes absolutely you can reach lifetime maximums in an insurance policy even Medicare.

I would think,hospitals are able to claim on bad debt reporting as charitable care as long as the patient is not in an acute setting and moved to a more long term facility. Not full reimbursement but not a full loss either.