My only complaint about Reverends is that the stock tuners are pretty lame. My BH5 has the upgraded tuners, but it's the only one with them. One of the tuners on my 5L is not doing really well, but I don't play it much so it's OK for now. All of the other ones on my fish are fine but don't feel very sturdy.
The hipshots are MUCH better than the stock Gotoh (or whatever they are).
Classy move to offer Matt some help there, Chef.
BTW, I finished putting together my ultimate lightweight rig and posted a thread with some pics in the amps section. The fish sound incredible through it.