The Stark E was a thud pretty much and the pitch centers were getting wavy. I couldn't touch it without my hand turning black.
hmmm, internal collapse of spiral core. sounds like some serious corrosion/oxidation as well... do you clean the sweat and rosin off your strings after a gig? but given your heavy hand and intensive use of this string, no wonder. Held up for three years, not bad at all... Can't complain about that. I think it was David Gage that said in one of his articles that E strings tend to wear out first. Anyway sounds like that Stark E was real far gone, deader than I've ever seen.
The A was losing power and focus, the notes had become short. The D sounded kinda flat and was getting thuddy as well.
That's the more usual wear and tear. Strings not completely gone but tone is noticably fading fast. That's what usually passes for Dead. In the past i've sometimes replaced mine even before they get that far. But then I was just doing what my teacher originally told me when i was starting out, he says: "New strings every year." Not really needed with Spiros... After I read Dr. Rod's comments in the "Unbowability Myth" thread i changed my mind and Spiros will stay on mine a lot longer.
The G actually sounded really good and I was contemplating leaving it. I so rarely like a Spiro G I was afraid I'd just hate the new one.
I hated new Spiro G's too, twangy sounding for the first few months. Maybe you'll put the old one back on!

.