• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Thunderbird Club

Absolute speculation on my part (with a few data points that give rise to the speculation).

I am guessing that they are not writing songs in English.

The experience from the Eurovision Song Contest is that to be successful outside of the contest, the band(s) must write songs in English. And thinking about that for a minute, about 25% of the world speak English as a result of British colonialism. Amongst non-native English speakers, English is the most common second language. Learning a second language adds less than 10% to lifetime earnings unless that second language is English in which case it is about a 25% increase in lifetime earnings. English is the international language of commerce and science (and probably many other things of which I am unaware). So, I speculate that to be successful in music you need to have English songs. Notable exceptions would include Rammstein (and can't think of any others off the top of my head).


I get your point but there are a lot of bands from other South American countries that sing in Spanish and have big hits, Argentina and Columbia have had very successful bands. I think part of it is a self fulfilling prophecy, no rock band from here has ever been successful from Peru so they don't try but there's also very little support here. I have seen some very good bands here though.

This is a very interesting band from Peru, UCHPA, they are part folklore and modern and sing in a language called Quechua from the mountains, I've seen them, they're very good live, song about beer



Here's some recent straight ahead rock bands from Peru who sing in English, the problem is they're not really very original.





Soda Stereo (Gustavo Cerati) and Juanes are two off the top of my head who sold a lot of records out here. I think both Columbia and Argentina are much more rock oriented countries though and support the music, out here? Naa. But spanish music is big business in the Spanish speaking countries.

I bought this album when it was current: Siempre es Hoy- Gustavo Cerati He came from a band called Soda Stereo from Argentina who were very well known here, still are,



Juanes from Colombia- I also bought this when it was new.

 
Last edited:
It appears the new Epi triangular case is a bit longer than my other from 2014. The VP fits with room to spare.

28D0C043-3D66-4F78-8D32-9814F77178C2.jpeg
 
:laugh: You tell 'em Jeff. Some people just have no couth.

I do like "couth" - it is mostly a proper way to label the un-couth. As in, you would not hear someone say; "that person lacks couth"... mostly used followed by "un".

Some other terms related; awkward, barbaric, boorish, cheap, clownish, coarse, crass, crude, discourteous, gawky, graceless, gross, heavy-handed, ill-bred, ill-mannered, impertinent, impolite, inelegant, loud, loutish.

hummm... why does this term sound so relevant? :rolleyes: (mic drop)
 
I get your point but there are a lot of bands from other South American countries that sing in Spanish and have big hits, Argentina and Columbia have had very successful bands. I think part of it is a self fulfilling prophecy, no rock band from here has ever been successful from Peru so they don't try but there's also very little support here. I have seen some very good bands here though.

This is a very interesting band from Peru, UCHPA, they are part folklore and modern and sing in a language called Quechua from the mountains, I've seen them, they're very good live, song about beer



Here's some recent straight ahead rock bands from Peru who sing in English, the problem is they're not really very original.





Soda Stereo (Gustavo Cerati) and Juanes are two off the top of my head who sold a lot of records out here. I think both Columbia and Argentina are much more rock oriented countries though and support the music, out here? Naa. But spanish music is big business in the Spanish speaking countries.

I bought this album when it was current: Siempre es Hoy- Gustavo Cerati He came from a band called Soda Stereo from Argentina who were very well known here, still are,



Juanes from Colombia- I also bought this when it was new.



I got to see The Warning last year (thanks @KaraQ for telling me to see them!); 3 sisters from Mexico. IIRC, they sing 1 song in Spanish, otherwise all English. Spending lots of time touring N America (and off to Europe this summer I think). Assuming that they continue to perform well and come up with more great music, they will be a success... Singing in English.
 
I got to see The Warning last year (thanks @KaraQ for telling me to see them!); 3 sisters from Mexico. IIRC, they sing 1 song in Spanish, otherwise all English. Spending lots of time touring N America (and off to Europe this summer I think). Assuming that they continue to perform well and come up with more great music, they will be a success... Singing in English.

Much bigger horizon singing English. The U.S. is the big enchilada.