I have to agree. This album we just released, we recorded all in our garage (two of us live together, and converted the garage to a studio/practice space), but inside of punching everything, I'd do two or three whole run throughs of the song (or as many as needed), and then pick the best take. The guitar player/engineer asked why not just punch in afterwards if there's a flub, but I prefer to be able to get the whole song in a single run, seems to just have a better flow, even if I could technically play a certain part better or whatever just punching in.