• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Timing - Bass and Drummer

DO NOT buy a drum machine yet.. If you're serious about synching it's much more forgiving to play with tons of activity.

  1. Lesson #1 - practice with a metronome (not drum machine)

Funny, but Ed Friedland -- who, for my money, is one of the most tuned-in bassists out there, and who has a knack for producing instructional techniques that work; see any of his many Hal Leonard titles, or look him up on YouTube -- says, in his book Bass Grooves: Develop Your Groove and Play Like the Pros in Any Style, pretty much exactly the opposite of what MNAirHead is propounding here: "While there are many active ways you can develop your groove, you can't just sit there with a metronome and become a groove monster" (11). While practicing with a metronome is a great way to develop time awareness, playing to a drum machine beat that you yourself have programmed (Ed goes into detail as to why this aspect is so important) is a much better way to develop groove awareness -- which, of course, are two very different aspects of playing the bass in an ensemble.

Just goes to show that different techniques work for different teachers, and there's *usually* no single right way to approach any given instructional or learning issue.

Jawbone, I'd definitely recommend picking up an inexpensive programmable drum machine -- they can be had all over ebay relatively cheaply -- and learning to make it walk and talk. Then get Bass Grooves and start working from it. I'm having a blast with it, learning a ton, and I suspect your experience will be similar. By the time you're done with the book, you'll be telling -- and showing! -- drummers how to play with you.
 
Timekeeping is essential, but that might be one level down from the OP's question.

Most general rules on what to listen to (bassdrum, hihat, snare), are pretty awkward, because there are worlds of difference between f.e. a jazz drummer (who might build a groove on his cymbals or a pop drummer who leans on bass and snare.

I disagree with Jimmy on drums having to follow the bass player - or with anybody who might say the opposite. If either drummer or bass player tries to lead the way, imposing his groove on the other, theyre bound to go wrong. Follow the flow is my advice. Close your eyes, listen well and let the waves carry you.

Unfortunately some people (both drummers and bassists) just cannot follow, because they are too busy playing their own stuff to be able to listen to others at the same time. So if there are no waves at all, I would call that a fine reason to evaluate your memberschip of that band.
 

Latest posts