Tone %

[quatre03]

not sure where to put this but:

i've been told that strings, pickups, woods, poweramps, preamps, speakers, and hundreds of other things define your basses tone.

What are the %'s of each of the diffrent element contributes to your over all tone.

 

[Brandt Scanlan]

I don't think this is something that is really quantifiable. Furthermore, it seems to me that different basses' tones are not necessarily made up of the same elements, or not to the same degree. For instance, my old jazz bass's sound would vary quite a bit depending on whether I used nickel strings or stainless steel strings. In contrast, stingrays all sound quite similar regardless of the strings used on them. Not to say that the type of strings makes no difference, but it is much easier to tell rounds from flats on a jazz than it is on stingray to my ears. I would assume that other factors have varying effects on the tones of varying basses.

 

[geoffkhan]

IMO:

strings: 20% (considering they're brand-new strings and not dead ones)
pickups: 20%
woods: 20%
amp: 40%

The amp totally makes my sound happen. Usually when I'm going DI my bass sounds pretty crummy, but as soon as I plug it into my amp, I get a great growl, and great Marcus Miller slap tone. My amp is great.

 

[Aussiephoenix]

I think you forgot a very important part...

IMO:
Hands -> 20%
Wood -> 40%
Pickups -> 20%
Strings -> 5%
Amp -> 15%

 

[Eric Moesle]

Not quantifiable. Anyone posting otherwise is just guessing. This isn't a mathematical science, nowhere even close.

 

[IvanMike]

Me - 99%
everything else - 1%

 

[Tom Howland]

 

[Tom Howland]

50%-equipment
50%-player

 

[Thee]

Hey, whats this can of worms doing here?

Personally, color of bass is like, 80%. At least. The other ~20% is the relative position of the planets and the stars.