• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Versitality of P Basses?

meatwad said:
The P is mighty! It can heal the sick, mend broken hearts, and make you a mean turkey sandwich.

The most interesting bass in the world.

150px-Jonathan_Goldsmith_2009.jpg
 
I've owned multiple P's and J's, and I've used both models for lots of different types of music. The J with one of its two pickups so close to the bridge gives a little more treble bite to my ears, but if you string a P with Rotosounds or something similar you'll get a nice growl also. Although they sound different tone-wise to me, I think both are suitable for a variety of genres. It comes down to which sound you like better. If either had to serve as my one and only bass, I'd be OK with it.
 
Not really a one trick pony. A Precision can be very dark and boomy, but also very bright because of the very powerful open polepiece pickup wired in series. There's a lot you can get out of the tone knob, and there's nay a situation where a P won't fit.

As has been said, the tone also comes from your technique, though most of the time it will still sound like a P. That's not a bad thing though, as I love the sound of a Precision. Most people do, it's all over most popular music.
 

It's about time to watch 2001 again isn't it?

Anyhow. I have been playing a Precision since 2002 through Country, Rock of all eras, Big Band, Blues, classic & newer R & B, and as I work through the different types of music I've never once thought, "I wish I had a _____ bass for this."

All basses a great. Especially the new ones these days. It's just what you put into making the song work.

After a while, you gotta quit blaming the gear.
 
Father: "What's the problem sonny, you look sad?"
Son: "Well, I have this Precision bass and I just can't play the bass lines of All Night Long with it... I have tried and tried for a week now and this bass just don't cut it.
Father: "So what would then help?
Son: "Definitely if I get a Jazz bass, then this bass line is easy to play."
Father opens up his huge wallet, shows it to his son and says: "Ok, let's go to the nearest Guitar Center."