Just reread Thomas Kuhn, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. It is the source of the much abused phrase "paradigm shift". It shifted my world view when I read it 45 years ago in college.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
A Psalm for the Wild-Built - Becky Chambers
The library hold finally came in! My wife read this book a few years ago and highly recommended it. It has become the book all other "cozy" sci-fi and fantasy novels are judged against for her. Time to see if it lives up to the hype and if "cozy" is a subgenre for me. My wife wants to revisit this book sometime, so if I like it, it will likely be added to the queue of books we read together.
View attachment 7214075
Thank you for this. The most recent time I re-read LOTR (several years ago now), I thought "What is the point of Tom Bombadil?". Looking at it from a 'travelogue' perspective, he makes more sense. The next time I read those books, I'll have a fresher perspective.One thing I've noticed about myself is that light beers, IPAs, and Chardonnay make no sense to me. I drink stout and chianti, because beer is supposed to be BROWN and wine is supposed to be RED. I realized a few years ago, I'm that way because of reading so much Tolkien so early. I've read the Silmarilion, the poems and tales in the short selection ("Adventures of Tom Bombadil" I think it was published as, though most of it isn't Bombadil material) and some of the posthumously published stuff from his notes, but not with the frequency or focus of the published novels.
I think probably the biggest question about Bombadil is whether he's essential to LOTR or not. Like I said, I think he's one of Tolkien's best creations. Every adaptation leaves him out, even the BBC radio play IIRC. The story of the quest of the Ring makes perfect sense without him. But reading it coming directly off a re-read of the Hobbit, one thing that strikes me about both books is that, in a way, they're kind of like the Odyssey. They aren't "action" stories, they're travel stories, and each stage of the journey is about a different kind of hospitality the travelers receive. So in the Hobbit, it's:
- Bilbo's hosting of the Dwarves
- Trolls
- Rivendell
- Goblins
- Gollum
- Eagles
- Beorn
- Spiders
- Wood-Elves
- Lake-Town
- Smaug
In Fellowship, it's
- Bilbo's Party
- Frodo hosts Gandalf
- Crickhollow (actually there's a series of brief guest/host events, with the traveling elves, and Farmer Maggot first)
- Tom Bombadil
- The Barrows
- Bree
- Rivendell (it might be a stretch, but you could almost see the journey between as Strider "hosting" the hobbits in the wilderness and at Weathertop).
- Moria
- Lothlorien
In a sense, a succession of visits in which the hosts variously feed, or try to feed on, their guests. From that perspective, Bombadil is an essential example of idealized hospitality. Just my own amateur attempts at literary interpretation.
A tribute to the architect who designed homes with leaky roofs?
Any plans for publication? Would be cool to read something written by someone from TB!I'm trying my hand at writing some historical fiction. Along with all of the resources available online, I plan on reading, or at least sampling the following:
Robinson Crusoe - Defoe
The Castle of Otranto - Walpole
King Solomon's Mines - Haggard
Captain Blood - Sabatini
and all of this Lovecraft:
At The Mountains of Madness
The Nameless City
The Temple
The Call of Cthulhu
Any plans for publication? Would be cool to read something written by someone from TB!
If you enjoyed that, you need to schedule a visit to Tulsa and tour downtown. The architecture is mind-blowing! I take it for granted sometimes.
Go to the Articles section on here: Art Deco Tulsa | Discover Tulsa’s Art Deco HistoryWeird. In everything I have read on Mr. Art Deco, Tulsa never came up!![]()