i'm about midbass so i'm down with the 58. almost used one on my gig tonight. my rider is slightly old, and there was a time when i was into the di + 58, but now i want a mic only when it's a good cab so i chickened out and had them put up a 421 instead. gotta update the rider.
I am more concerned with midbass also nowdays, and not worried about getting a very subby sound, so a 57 or 58 works for me.
Rant time! -
One of my big issues with the very hardheaded, hard to work with soundguys, is that they think there is only ONE "good" bass tone, guitar sound, etc - and try to mix every band the same regardless of style. The few GOOD soundmen I have had dealings with made it part of their job to understand stylistic differences among different styles of music and mix accordingly. (they actually listen to music!) If I were a soundman (and I may be some day) I would make sure I understood what type of sound the band playing is going for and mix them accordingly, within the constraints of the venue and sound system.
Case in point: - I played with a classic Honky Tonk band over the summer. I play upright bass, so it is especially challenging. I talked with the very pigheaded soundguy till I was blue in the face (very nicely and politely) about specifics required when amplifying upright bass. Our set started, and I had instant howling feedback. He had me in the goddamn monitors which I specifically told him NOT to do. He also blasted the kick drum through the subs (on either side of the stage!) even though I told him we play classic country and a "big" LOUD subby kick drum sound IS NOT wanted. Long story short, it was a crappy night. The guy paid absolutely NO attention to my requests whatsoever, because he knows everything apparently.
Second case: I played in a traditional Rocksteady / Reggae band for almost ten years. Despite all my shmoozing, beer buying, and ass-kissing soundguys over the years, almost none of them knew how to mix a reggae band. They would bitch about the subby bass tone (you ain't got no treble, mayun!) , blast the guitars for no reason (rawk out!) , and generally mix us the same way as the AC/DC cover bands that played the night before. Time and time again, we begged and pleaded for a certain mix, and time and time again our requests were completely ignored.
Most of my gigging has been at the small club level, so maybe it gets better farther up the food chain, I don't know.