I have 2 P-basses - one old, scabby unbranded one (actually has a hewlett packard badge on the headstock) from punk days gone by, and my 2021 MIM player P. The old one has super dead 20yr old strings and actually sounds quite unique in a thumpy way. Horrible to play in comparison to my MIM player P, which beats it in every single way and is what I gig with in my covers band.
However, we are starting to cover some songs that have quite a bit of slap on them (call me al, car wash, Never too much), and while I can slap it well enough, it is still the P-bass clank tone and does not really sound "right" Either a bit too bassy or over bright and metallic sounding (to me, anyway). We also want to cover songs like Waterfalls - TLC, which means i must detune down a 1/2 step quickly on all 4 strings, so I can play it!
So... the justification for buying a 5 string Jazz bass has created itself, and I will be soon getting a Squier CV70s 5 string Jazz bass, passive old school cool.
No way can I afford the "proper" Fender 5 string Jazz basses, they all start at crazy prices. I don't like the look of Sires, and tried out the Ibanez SR300 and Yamaha TRBX similar basses, didn't like the feel of them. The sire M2 series, didn't like the look or feel of it (I have sausage fingers). The Squier CV70s Jazz V in natural wood with black pickguard, looks sweet, plays fluidly, sounds spot-on for slap tones of the songs I play, and it has that deep low B, opening up far easier ways to play songs (Aint' nobody, waterfalls, Beck - Loser, Dance monkey etc etc). When you play a bass and it straight away feels "right", and meets your needs, then the missus surely cannot complain...?
AC