• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

What if there was only original band

Would you play if there is only original band


  • Total voters
    141
at my age, a total waste of time. I have no interest in trying to "make it". Even if I was young, I think it's delusional. So few artists or bands really make it these days. even if you do get some fame, there's not much money in it. It's simply a poor use of your prime working years if you're looking at it financially.

and where I live, the demand for original music is virtually nil. I'd rather have fun, get paid and give the people what they wish. How many of you have headlined internationally for more than 10,000 people? I have and I've never did it doing originals. I just don't think it would be worth my time.

for those of you who love doing originals, I say have it! for me, it's a dead-end
 
Would you play if there was only original band. Whatever the genre if you to get in front of people you can only play the music you created.

I would be miserable. I love my favorite hits. People who go to bars live their favorite hits. People like to celebrate to music. It reminds them of good times. It tugs at their emotions in ways few other things can. I'm not opposed to originals. But I can't imagine a music scene with ONLY originals.

Call me crazy. But I LOVE playing a smash hit in a bar when the crowd is singing so loud I could stop singing and they wouldn't know it.
 
I would be miserable. I love my favorite hits. People who go to bars live their favorite hits. People like to celebrate to music. It reminds them of good times. It tugs at their emotions in ways few other things can. I'm not opposed to originals. But I can't imagine a music scene with ONLY originals.

Call me crazy. But I LOVE playing a smash hit in a bar when the crowd is singing so loud I could stop singing and they wouldn't know it.
You're not crazy—it's a rush that's hard to top.
You DID leave out the butts moving part, which to my mind is the hallmark of a successful gig.
 
I came up in the '70s New York City club scene and it was all-originals, all the time. Maybe 1 or 2 covers a set, and those were generally stylistic re-workings. To be sure, there we some retro trip bands, notably the then new Neo-Rockabilly, but these acts were going for something outside the norm rather than playing 'the hits.'
It was a damn exciting time with lots of great innovative players and artists (lots of bad ones, too!)
 
at my age, a total waste of time. I have no interest in trying to "make it". Even if I was young, I think it's delusional. So few artists or bands really make it these days. even if you do get some fame, there's not much money in it. It's simply a poor use of your prime working years if you're looking at it financially.

and where I live, the demand for original music is virtually nil. I'd rather have fun, get paid and give the people what they wish. How many of you have headlined internationally for more than 10,000 people? I have and I've never did it doing originals. I just don't think it would be worth my time.

for those of you who love doing originals, I say have it! for me, it's a dead-end
I understand that for you your Time equal money. For me I prefer to feel happy and fulfilled
 
  • Like
Reactions: McTred and Heady