• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

What is your favorite Rush album?

Originally posted by embellisher
I originally hated Power Windows, but over the years it has grown on me. It's probably in my top 5.

*bump!*

I'm bringing this back to the top becasue I finally gave PW the chance it deserves. I only got into Rush last November or so, I downloaded a bunch of MP3's off each album, loved it, went out and bought 2112-Signals, downloaded more MP3's, needed more CD's, went for GUP, HYF and Presto next...

Notice I skipped Power Windows... everything I had heard off it just sounded too 80's synthey... I didn't mind Emotion Detector...

Anyway, fast forward to just last week, I've been major-digging HYF, so I thought "hey, I should give PW another try". Put on my headphones, sat down and played Grand Designs. I was remotely intrigued... I took off the headphones, fired up the ol' hi-fi, and bickety-bam! It finally hit me.

There's a lot of studio wizardry and stereo stuff that just doesn't come through right on headphones. PW is a sonically HUGE album, it just sounds massive when you blast it on a nice hi-fi. Now I'm hooked. Middletown Dreams is my favourite track, with Grand Designs as a pretty close second.

I don't *love* The Big Money, but then again, I think I'm also the only person who doesn't *love* Tom Sawyer, or Limelight, or Closer to the Heart...

I'd say PW is probably on my top three Rush albums list...

Anyway, I've been sick all week so hopefully tomorrow I'll have the energy to go buy the actual cd and RTB, which i've also been jonesing for.

Give PW a chance!

--jeff
P.S.: From what I've read, everyone was mad at Rush for making Signals, which was much more synth-ey than MP. GUP only sealed the deal - Rush were definitely not on the track the "early era" fans hoped for. I, however, applaud them for not staying still, for refusing to stay static. I'm sure they could have cranked out a few more Moving Pictures-type albums, then called it a day. But they didn't - and they're STILL evolving! Wow.
 
"Power Windows" grew on me, too, after a while. Not in my top 5, though.. maybe not even top 10! I'd have to say "Moving Pictures" is my favorite, followed by "Hemispheres" and "Caress of Steel." And I, personally, would rank "Rush," "Fly by Night," "A Farewell to Kings," "2112," "Permanent Waves," "Signals," "Exit: Stage Left," "Grace Under Pressure," and "Counterparts" ahead of "Power Windows."
But, that's just me. And I still think "Power Windows" is pretty damn good! It was just so jarring when it came out, a real radical change for them.
"Vapor Trails" comes out May 14th, and the tour starts in the United States on June 28th. Haven't seen any other dates or cities yet. I'm leaving town July 12-20, and I just know they're gonna play Atlanta while I'm gone!
 
BarnacleBassist asked...

and you got the vapor trails cd eh?

what is the best song on it?

and any crazy basslines?

!!!:confused: !!!


I'm about the same age as Geddy (actually he's three years older than I am) so what appeals to me might not be the same as what you'd like, but I like the title track, Earthshine and Out Of The Cradle the best so far.

Crazy basslines? Lots of them. Geddy seems to be playing more strings at the same time than on any other Rush album.
 
I'm about the same age as Geddy (actually he's three years older than I am) so what appeals to me might not be the same as what you'd like, but I like the title track, Earthshine and Out Of The Cradle the best so far.

Crazy basslines? Lots of them. Geddy seems to be playing more strings at the same time than on any other Rush album. [/B][/QUOTE]

Hey thats cool about the age...

and YAY! good basslines! more to learn! :D
 
I'm only 15, so maybe I don't know what the big Rush kick is all about. I've heard so much on here that I figured I should check them out. So, I downloaded Limelight and Red Barchetta off KaZaA. I don't know, but it sounded a lot like 80's pop, especially their vocalist. My god! The music sounded pretty cool, but I can't get past the fact that their singer sounds like the guy from Queen, and the whole thing just sounds corny. Maybe there's something wrong with me.